Page MenuHomePhabricator

Maintenance_script and MediaWiki_default lack bot rights on fresh installs
Closed, DeclinedPublicBUG REPORT

Description

Steps to replicate the issue:

  • Start a new wiki
  • Go to Special:ListUsers

What happens?:

  • There are two bots called User: MediaWiki default and User: Maintenance script
  • These are both bots, but they do not have the bot user right by default.

What should have happened instead?:

  • Because they are bots, they should have the bot user right.

Software version
1.45

Event Timeline

They are not bots, they are used by MediaWiki directly, and as a result, they usually skip permission / rate limit checks altogether.

It would be more useful to make sure that they have a user page (and that they are centralized - that's T275931: Have new system users be automatically attached to CentralAuth)

They are not external bots, but rather internal bots, are they not? They are not human users, anyway.

They're system users, which is not really the same thing as bots (it's not even a user group). We don't display that status on Special:ListUsers, maybe we should.

We'd need a cheaper way of detecting systemuser-ness then. (See T212720: System users should be in a dedicated user group for some relevant discussion.)

I don't think this should be changed.