https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Lead_section#Length
This task proposes a suggestion that would prompt people to revise lead sections that surpass MoS length requirements.
Story
As a volunteer who is motivated to ensure articles offer readers a concise overview of the topic they're interested in, I'd value knowing when the lead section of an article I'm editing surpasses the length guidelines defined in my wiki's content guidelines, so that readers, especially those on mobile, can quickly grasp the article's key points.
As a reader who wants to get summarized information quickly (internal WMF link), I would value the lead section remaining short.
Meta
- Relevant wish, policy, guideline, template, etc.: en:Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Lead_section#Length
- Suggestion scope:
Requirements '
Meta
- Default configuration
- maximumEditcount:
- minimumEditcount: 25 edits
- Type: Suggestion and/or Check: Suggestion
- Detection heuristic: Lead section length (words)
- Note: I can see a future where the heuristic is more comprehensive and includes a range of features. E.g. length, existence of unique information, reading level, etc.
User experience
- Card design
- Title: Improve readability
- Description (≤2 sentences): This section is longer than Wikipedia guidelines recommend. Consider making it shorter by doing things like moving information into other sections or replacing long phrases with simpler ones.
- Calls to action
- Revise: Activate the bounded text-editing state the ToneCheck.js introduced
- Dismiss: Activate "dismiss survey" that invites people to share why they think the lead section is acceptable as it is.
- Calls to action
- Success toast
Instrumentation
As with all Edit Checks and Suggestions, we will want to know:
- Any time a Suggestion of this type is activated within an edit session
- Any time someone views a Suggestion of this type within an edit session
- Any time someone engages with a Suggestion and how they engage with it