Blocked on T416894

Hey @Etonkovidova, I tried reproducing this on both testwiki 1.46.0-wmf.13 and my local setup, but no luck reproducing it. Are you still seeing this on your end?
cc @Sdkb

@AAlhazwani-WMF , just a quick clarification: for declined suggestions, what’s the intended behavior on both mobile and desktop? Should it display a success toast message, or a notice toast message? cc: @Michael

Thank you @Etonkovidova for raising this. This behavior is expected given the current GE homepage/overlay architecture. The notification link targets Special:Homepage and the overlay opens based on client-side routing after load, so the brief homepage flash happens before the dialog is shown. Changing that would require reworking how the overlay is initialized and resolved on mobile, which would be a much larger change than this fix.

@Etonkovidova, I’m not sure if it’s just me, but the attached images aren’t displaying on my end. I also tested this on enwiki beta, and the desktop message still says “Thanks for reviewing suggestions. Keep going!” which doesn’t match the A/C for the task: “You’ve reviewed a suggestion. Thanks and keep going!” On mobile, the message is “You’ve published an edit. Thanks and keep going.” I think both views need updates?

I tested this on mobile(where the regression was happening) on test wiki and it looks like the issue was fixed by this patch: https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/mediawiki/extensions/GrowthExperiments/+/1216798.

This patch only addresses the checkbox removal, not the help panel integration.

In T397193#11502926, @Sgs wrote:

I'm not sure we tested the same flow, for (1) and (2) I was referring to the original steps to replicate from this issue description, which I assume are on mobile. Here's a video of what I'm observing.

@Michael , should I go ahead and mark this task as resolved, since logstash hasn’t shown any errors for over a week? Also, should we resolve the associated tasks at the same time, or wait until QA formally closes them? cc : @Sgs