In T438582#12410269, @Sgs wrote:

For the scope of the pilot release we agreed with @Michael on restricting Home only to the users who have Homepage enabled. Looking for confirmation, cc @KStoller-WMF.

This work has already started as part of T434036: Early communications: gather community feedback on Home plans and designs, however it's likely time to follow up and get clearer with communities about what is and is NOT included in this Pilot release.

No questions or concerns! I agree that it makes sense to show edit suggestions if a person navigates back into edit the same article after completing a newcomer task.

Thanks for the thorough summary of ideas and designs!

The experiment has started and we can see initial results in GrowthBook, so I think we can consider this task complete.

Shift from OOUI to Codex.

Oh, and apparently we actually do some filtering on the ML side to attempt to exclude tables. I think there are just some exceptions depending on formatting used.

IIUC, the Growth team's variant of this feature already excludes tables

Definitely not a requirement or release blocker, so I’m moving this to “Low” priority. That said, if it’s easy to implement, I think it’s worth adding more fun UX moments like this.

Not sure if there is a great way to fully test this, but I have:

I guess I'm not sure what is a patchdemo limitation vs. missing functionality, but a few quirks I noticed:

@Mayakp.wiki I don't have a strong preference here, so I think aligning with how we have the newcomer retention rate defined makes sense.