Jan 28 2019
@Tgr Would it be possible to also add the upload_by_url right to the patroller group per https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Village_pump/Proposals&oldid=336738154#Make_the_%22more_upload_options%22_proposal_apply_to_all_user_accounts_with_autopatrol_flag? Or should I create a new ticket for that?
Jan 20 2019
Jan 17 2019
@AlexisJazz Obviously there was some confusion between user groups and user rights which is understandable. I personally don't have a problem with including the patroller user group in this request since, as you said, patroller is an "upgrade" to the autopatrolled group as it is currently defined on Commons. I didn't read your original proposal as meaning "add upload_by_url to every group that has the autopatrol flag" but I guess I could read it that way also. If another RfC is required to grant the flag to the patroller group as well then so be it. But that would be up to the devs who actually make those changes whether or not they want to include the patroller group since it is set up to be an extension of autopatrolled on Commons.
Nov 27 2018
I would have to agree that the ability to block the person who blocked you would mitigate the problems with small wikis that have very few admins that the removal of this permission presents. At least with that there is the ability to stop the damage being done if the entire admin staff is blocked by a compromised account. Non-compromised accounts can be easily unblocked and the vandalism would be stopped. As for rate limits I really don't think that is a good idea. The limit would need to be set so high as to be rather useless as to not interfere with the normal administrative duties that occur.
Why was this done globally instead of just to enwiki as requested? No other project requested this as far as I'm aware. To remove unblockself from all wikis, especially smaller ones where there are only one or two admins, raises a bunch of problems. It would be better if the devs only did this on the projects that requested it instead of extending the massive paranoia to every single project.
Nov 10 2018
Not to put a damper on this idea but did we all forget about cascading semi-protection? That was removed because it would have allowed non-admins to perform admin actions. Unless we were to restrict adding and removing categories to admins only this would allow anyone to block people under this type of partial block from additional pages. Which is something that should probably be avoided.
Oct 18 2018
Apparently this is greater than one image. So far 15 images could not be successfully deleted per https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Deletion_bug