A nice UI would be great. Solving the open issues and making the charts work is also something we urgently need.

Somehow, it is back.

Good example. Then null is not a solution. It solves part of the issue (taking fake numbers) but the line should be continous. I assume that each line should be taken as completely independent.

If I understand the issue correctly, adding a 0 can't be the solution.

I can't make width and height parameters to work, but the results are coming. I have checked the module, and the width and height parameters are missing.

Thanks! That's what I have been looking for in the last two years!

I have tried now one below, and it works only for Elo ratings. I want to show population charts, so I think I need to create an specific chart fot that at Commons, isn't it?

@Wellverywell I have copied the module and the template but this is not working at euwiki:

In T407747#11290273, @DLynch wrote:

As an interim workaround, reloading the page should preserve the edit via VE's autosave. (Which, obviously, won't help if it turns out to be reproducible for a given edit, but...)

Are you saying that our engineers took a software that will be unable to do "plot a point at x=2, y=5 and another one at x=3, y=6". Because that's a very wild declaration.

Folks have already figured out how to do that: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Module:Graph:Chart (β).

most things that aren't supported today in Charts will remain unsupported

There are a good bunch of tickets filled with those, but the problem is a design problem: the team solved something without looking first on how the software was used. That's why the new charts thing is not able to replace the old graphs. You can see that there's still a huge amount of broken graphs.

Perhaps a new ticket "New Charts extension should achieve 100% feature parity with old Graphs extension" should also be created

The problem is that the solution given can't be used to replace the broken graphs, at least at euwiki. So this is not an on-wiki project, this is a core issue of a deficient solution.

As this is still broken, and no solution is given to most of the graphs used, it should remain open.

Please avoid off-topic questions in resolved tasks.

Oh! Then the documentation lacks that information.

I have been testing OSM Location map and I'm sorry to say that it doesn't cover what Graph:Street map with marks used to cover. Kartographer can load data from a Wikidata query, Graph could load data from a Wikidata quety, but OSM Location map can only add individual points, without Wikidata query integration. The template is good, but can't be named as a substitute, as it doesn't do the same thing.

We can use Kartographer extension to show points, there's no need to localize OSM Location map for that. However, it should be mentioned that Charts will be unable to do things that Graphs was able to do, and all the graphs using location data should be moved to use Kartographer.

I don't know how cache was handled in graphs, I understand that data was cached in the same way you mention. We should have *at least* the same data ingesting methods as we had before. So, if the data should be, for technical reasons, cached for some days, let it be cached.

Thanks @OwenBlacker. As far as I have tested, that solution doesn't import the data nor graphs we are talking about here.

Are you mistakenly under the impression that existing uses of the graph extension will magically start working under charts?

In that case, yes, it works. However, we can't see them.

That's the population graph, not the weather graph. There are two graphs in the same article.

• Commons Data:*.tab files – covered by the MVP

The original graph comes from here: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Template:Graph:Weather_monthly_history

Ok this looked like this before:

No, it didn't render like that.

the system is that it can take Data: pages and render them to charts with the key features of a chart.

I don't know what MVP stands for.

This is outside scope of the MVP for Charts Task Force

The task is actionable: "Charts should work at least for the use cases graphs had"

Yes, that's an example of two graphs that worked and now are impossible with charts.

In T334940#10883822, @Prototyperspective wrote:

The Charts extension has now been deployed also to English Wikipedia. For those interested in re-enabling interactive charts by converting graphs to the new Chart extension, see this tool graphDataImport which makes this quick & easy and also the alternatives in the See also section there. Anything related to any of this can be asked in this new WikiProject.

We had two graphs here: https://eu.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altsasu. How do we make them adapt to charts? Thanks!

I have tried to use this linking a category and it doesn't work.

Does this mean that things like https://humaniki.wmcloud.org/ will be working again?

Yesterday I had a meeting with the responsible for heritage at the Basque Government. She told me that they are trying to have lots of "digital twins" (i.e. 3D objects), but they don't have a good place to have them online. We neither! Just imagine the possibilities.

Fixed at euwiki. Thanks!

You can check with this one at euwiki: https://eu.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebenau

Found the same issue at euwiki now.

After some weeks without being logged out, in the last two days I have been logged out randomly from Wikipedia, Commons and Wikidata, and even logging in for one of them doesn't globally log in for the others.

The issue wans't at the family declaration, but was interesting: the script couldn't read a wiki I haven't visited before. Just opening each of the neglected wikis solved the issue.

I think that the problem is that the list at the source code was outdated. I'm checking again, but it is loading now some other languages. Thanks for checking that the family declaration was up to date.

I'm using pwb.py ListExpandedSample, no other command added. The source code is here: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wikipedias_by_expanded_sample_of_articles/Source_code and lists 323 languages, which seems correct.

In T383920#10471470, @rook wrote:

Hello could the link in the ticket be updated to a hyperlink?

Solved! Thanks!

Just for tracking the issue: I have been logged out every day, sometimes even twice, in the last week. I don't know if the solution given is improving something, but I'm just seing the opposite.

I was logged in at 09:13 and logged out from euwiki at 09:15. Only clicking at recent changes, nothing more.

Now logged out from euwiki (~16:45 CET) but still logged in at Meta:

After some weeks where I wasn't totally logged-out, and just clicking on the login button would auto-log me again, in the last two days I have been logged out totally many times, and even being logged at euwiki didn't central log me into Wikidata, where I was asked again the 2FA.

There's no perfect solution, nor one-size-fits-all solution here. That's right. We should have two very different approaches, in my opinion:

I think that we are building the things upside down. While this is interesting, the most experiences users know which templates to choose, because they are experienced. The problem in T55590 is the opposite: how do new contributors know what are the most obvious or used templates?

Just look at this cc-by cast: https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/homo-neanderthalensis-skull-cast-a1ffe02b7e2f42ff972953484f3212d3

Strangely enough, today I was logged out from Meta, but not from Basque Wikipedia. I needed to log again at Meta, with 2FA, but I wasn't logged out from euwiki, as usually happens.

I use basically Basque wikipedia and only on Firefox, so is not limited to Chrome and English.

This happened again today, so I don't know if the restart system is working or it will take a while.

I don't remember all the steps now, but I think @Jdlrobson helped with some css (??)

Yes, that is solved.

Till last week this was happening usually, and I only needed to log-in again clicking on the "log in" button, it made it automatically without needing to enter the password again. Since there's a "Donate" button next to the log-in button, I have to fully log-in again, and I use F2A, so it is even more annoying.

Thanks!