Right. Since the Editing Team has switched priorities to Talk pages, this
has been put in the freezer for a bit.
Tue, Sep 10
Mon, Sep 9
Fri, Sep 6
What would it look like if we:
Wed, Sep 4
I haven't thought these through 100% but since @Esanders pre-empted the conversation over in T208738, here are a few mockups that I've been tinkering with. These show a few specific attempts at highlighting edit vs read mode:
Tue, Sep 3
This work is being done in conjunction with T229030.
I have done a comparative review in the slide deck about the proposed changes to the look and feel of the toolbar.
Sat, Aug 31
I added the following remaining open questions to the team notes document:
Updated the flow here and on Freehand.
Fri, Aug 30
[[ https://wikimedia.invisionapp.com/freehand/document/s1duRw6io | Here's ]]my first round of tweaks, would love to hear some feedback @cmadeo
I agree and think this should be at a minimum in all the mobile dialogs (I'm less sure about desktop but can loop back and check).
To make sure this doesn't break anything, I will bring it up in the style guide meeting next week.
I updated the description with the edit card ui design sub-task ticket T231649
Thu, Aug 29
This work should happen in conjunction with the toolbar v1 release @DLynch
Does this mockup represent the issues that we need to address with legal:
This is what the link edit card currently looks like:
Wed, Aug 28
I'd mark this as done.
In usertesting we learned:
As our user testing at Wikimania Stockholm confirmed, this is working well.
Has @Ryasmeen had a chance to do a QA review on it?
Tue, Aug 27
Bumping this ticket as it came up several times at Wikimania Stockholm usability testing.
Aug 8 2019
I ran the tests on usertesting.com (which is reflected in the ticket description).
Here is a summary of the results:
I suggest that we close this ticket. I'm removing the editing design tag.
I ran the test.
Aug 5 2019
Can you provide a screenshot of that?
When the text limit is being reached, how does this appear?
copying the comments from @DannyH on chat:
Aug 2 2019
I am pulling together my current thinking for research at Wikimania in this slide deck.
A few thoughts:
As you can see in this screenshot, the user has absolutely no instructions or context about what they are supposed to be doing. So, there's a few options:
Aug 1 2019
Action Item: Write Interview questions for on the fly interviews.
👏nice job @Esanders - it was bugging me!
Dropping notes from conversation with @ppelberg here:
When we introduced the "publish" wording a few years ago, we clearly missed this message. "Save >changes" should be "Publish changes".
I mocked up a few different options for discussion purposes (on Invision, copying here for documentation)
Jul 31 2019
Here are the next steps that we identified (some which might need to be turned into sub-tasks of this ticket):
I agree with this approach because it feels jargony to me.