Aug 4 2018
Just wanted to post that @maskaravivek 's solution works for me (for the most part). If no issues, we will be pushing a release with this implementation very shortly. :)
Jun 15 2018
Jun 13 2018
I cherry-picked the change onto our 2.8-release branch - should be fine to just release this in 2.8, no need to wait for 2.9. :) Thanks @Nemo_bis !
Apr 26 2018
I saw your mailing list post. Nicely-written, well done! :)
Apr 25 2018
Hi @Tanvidadu1998 , I trust you received Srishti's email? :) I think you can start writing updates about your progress at https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Google_Summer_of_Code/2018#Community_bonding_period . So for instance if you subscribed to wikitech-l as we talked about yesterday, you can add that to your updates. Please feel free to carry on with the other community bonding period steps mentioned on that page, as well as the project-specific tasks that Vivek suggested like reading documentation, and update via that page as you go.
Apr 2 2018
Mar 29 2018
Hi @Aklapper , we extended our Outreachy deadline to Mar 29, and I can confirm that I see this proposal in my Outreachy dashboard.
Mar 25 2018
Mar 21 2018
Hi @maskaravivek , @K0x3rr spoke to me about the same thing over email, and I explained to him that this project is eligible for both GSoC and Outreachy, but that T188877 is reserved solely for GSoC. :)
Mar 20 2018
Thanks for submitting your proposal. It looks great to me in general, and the list of bugfixes is impressive! :)
@Gupta-meghna64 thanks for the update! The previous apps that you have worked on look amazing. Well done. :)
Mar 19 2018
Thanks @ayushin78 . :)
Thanks for the update, @harisanker24 !
Happy to see that you have updated your proposal! The new formatting looks great and much more readable. :)
Mar 18 2018
I agree with @maskaravivek - the outcome of the quiz should not affect reputation/points. :)
Thanks for submitting your proposal! :) It looks good to me in general, but I have a few suggestions:
- In the timeline it is good that you have frontloaded your work and allocated time for mockups, testing and debugging, etc. However, I personally think too little time is allocated for implementation. E.g. For Phase 1 I would recommend moving "Decide the information which will be displayed in the stats info page. Improve it through community discussion." up into the mockup week so that you have at least 2 weeks for implementation.
- We appear to be missing 5 days in June? ;) If you are allocating that time for writing your midpoint report, please do mention that.
Mar 16 2018
Nice to see you have submitted a proposal, and the apps you have worked on before look great. :) A few suggestions:
Mar 15 2018
Mar 13 2018
GitHub project link would be great!
Thanks for putting this proposal up. I am guessing that tasks and deliverables are still being worked on? That's totally fine, but I would recommend putting the deliverables next to the tasks in the table (in a 3rd column), that will make it easier for us to view them.
Glad to see that you are working on your proposal. :) I especially like the detailed task breakdowns - it's great that you have suggested documenting the results of various API strategies, and mockups for each UI phase.
Very thorough and well thought-out proposal, nice. :) I am very happy to see time allocated for testing and fixing bugs, and that the task details reflect the discussion we had in the relevant GitHub issues. A few suggestions:
Mar 5 2018
Feb 13 2018
Feb 12 2018
Jan 19 2018
Dec 18 2017
Should be fixed via https://github.com/commons-app/apps-android-commons/pull/1019 , thanks for bringing this to our notice!
Nov 29 2017
Update to all: After some discussion, we have been informed that this requirement has been waived, for the reasons mentioned here. Thank you for your patience and help, everyone. :)
Jun 5 2017
May 15 2017
May 14 2017
Apologies for reviving this, but it would be very useful for the Commons Android app if we could query this. Several users have requested to be able to see the total number of uploads they have made to Commons, but we are unable to show it to them.
Feb 27 2017
Feb 26 2017
Feb 17 2017
Dec 14 2016
This issue is currently tracked at https://github.com/commons-app/apps-android-commons/issues/144 , please refer there instead (sorry, @Aklapper , we had to do some housekeeping in our GitHub issues).
Nov 26 2016
Thanks for the suggestion. We do have plans to add more licenses to the app - the task is currently tracked at https://github.com/commons-app/apps-android-commons/issues/254 . Unfortunately I don't have the time currently to implement it, due to other commitments. However, I have outlined the steps needed for implementation on that GitHub thread, and it would make a good starter task for someone wanting to get involved with our codebase, so if any volunteers are interested in picking it up, that would be great. :) Alternatively, I could include it (along with adding explicit license selection, as the current license selection method is less than ideal) in my IEG renewal proposal at the start of next year.
Nov 25 2016
Hi @Qgil , yes I completed this task during the Dec 2015 Outreachy round. :)
Closing this, if anyone disagrees please feel free to reopen.
Oct 29 2016
Feature parity with the Android Commons app makes a lot of sense to me. I don't have much iOS experience, but my opinion is that using Swift might make it easier to recruit and on-board new volunteers, compared to a legacy app that is running Objective-C.
Oct 26 2016
My $0.02 as a woman and a first-time participant thinking of applying to attend the Wikimedia Hackathon 2017:
Oct 18 2016
Just to clarify, are you requesting this feature for the web-based Upload Wizard? Commons-App-Android-Upload is for the Commons Android app.
Oct 11 2016
Excellent, happy to hear that!
Oct 6 2016
This would be great. AFAIK there isn't even an 'unofficial' iOS app for this any more, last I checked it had been pulled from the store because the developer's account had expired (see here).
Sep 19 2016
@Aschroet - Ah, I looked into the developer console history to refresh my memory and yes, there was a mixup before. About a year ago, I was new to the app and it was my first release, so I mistakenly titled the release after 1.3 as '1.31'. :) I was informed of the error and fixed it, but that was a while later, so some uploads must have gone through.
Sep 17 2016
I will have to release a hotfix for another bug anyway, so no harm putting this in v1.31 and seeing how it goes. Do let me know. :)
Sep 16 2016
Sep 14 2016
Interesting, I'm not sure in what cases a picture would have a geolocation of (0,0). If the EXIF data did not exist it should be returning null, and thus excluded from appending the location template. I don't think this is as easy a fix as the previous one (unless we're okay with excluding location templates in cases where that value is found as well). Will ask on GitHub.
Sep 13 2016
Thanks @Aschroet . I forgot to clarify: updates do take a while to go through on Google Play, and users don't always update their apps immediately, so it might take a few days for any changes to get to the majority of users. But if the issue persists beyond that time frame, then I will need to look at it again. :)
We have released v1.30 of the app which should hopefully fix the issue. Please do let us know if it persists, thanks!
Sep 12 2016
Thanks for letting us know! We'll work on it (https://github.com/commons-app/apps-android-commons/issues/269)
Sep 6 2016
From memory, if I take photos of a well-known cafe, Google pops up one notification saying something like "Add 5 pictures to Punnet Cafe" or similar. It includes both photos of food etc as well as photos of the location, so I doubt image recognition plays a big part. If I recall correctly, it even includes selfies, which might be an issue in our case. (I know that the pictures displayed on Google Maps don't include selfies, so I'm guessing they filter them out after submission)
Jul 11 2016
Jul 7 2016
@Jane023 it is a built-in functionality that I wrote for the Android app about 6 months ago. I don't think it can be converted to the web uploader per se, different programming language entirely.
The Commons Android app already contains the functionality you are requesting, if I understand correctly. Not sure about the web-based Upload Wizard.
Jun 20 2016
The Android app for this does exist at https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=fr.free.nrw.commons . It supports the 'share' option, you can browse through your gallery, click 'share' and select our app from the list of potential apps displayed.
I think this has been settled. Could anyone confirm and close?
Mar 16 2016
Mar 14 2016
Mar 12 2016
Thanks @Qgil ! I glanced at the guidelines which suggested that I email firstname.lastname@example.org with the blog post idea first before writing a draft, so I've done that. Crossing my fingers.... :)
Mar 8 2016
@Niharika thanks! I had no idea we could speak at conferences about our projects. :)
Mar 7 2016
Final update: Not sure if this is where it should go, but I just wanted folks to know that the internship has been awesome - I've learnt heaps about FOSS, Android development and Wikimedia. And the community has been amazing. :) I'm very much hoping to stick around - I've submitted an IEG proposal for further work on the app, and I'll try to help or share my experiences with the next round of Outreachy applicants as well.
Just letting you know that we haven't forgotten, I have added your bug report to the list of bugfixes planned for the app as part of an IEG proposal. :) Would very much appreciate it if you could take a look at the proposal and review/endorse it if you see fit.
No probs Johan. :)
Thanks @Niharika , that would be great!
Mar 3 2016
Do you mean the features listed in the report? They have been implemented and are available in v1.12 of the app that was released on Feb 18.
Apologies, I would love to but will be unable to make the stipulated time (19:00 UTC, right?). But thanks for asking me, and do let me know if there is a way to work around that. :)
Thanks for asking me. :) What would that involve? Is there a page where I could read more about it?
Sure thing, thanks for the nudge @01tonythomas :)
Feb 29 2016
Thanks everyone, it's been a great ride! @Niharika I definitely plan to. :)