Hey @cooltey – @JTannerWMF and I would like to make some updates to the coffee roll design, could you implement it like this, please:

The survey’s now ready to be launched. The last updates included:

Added comments related to the coffee roll to T299033#8032181.

Hey @cooltey – the apk in the task’s description doesn’t seem to work correctly; see this video:

That sounds good @cooltey — ,and let’s work towards having more structured data in the future, that only features one signature; the one in the header of the message! 🚀

Thanks for creating the task @JTannerWMF. After looking at it with fresh eyes, I suggest keeping the designs simple, like this:

• Submitted the Survey privacy statement request form
• Related information:
  • Email thread: [foundation-optional] Updated Survey Privacy Statement Request Process
  • Onboarding survey for Android - Google Docs
  • Previous privacy statement: Legal:Wikipedia Android App Talk Page Survey Privacy Statement - Wikimedia Foundation Governance Wiki

looks good so far @cooltey – one question related to talk page signatures:

@cooltey – the apk in the ticket description seems outdated – I used this one to review:

It’d be great if @Dbrant or @cooltey could take a shot at implementing this, based on existing components in the app. I’ll happily review it thoroughly when it’s in design signoff. Trusting you with this 💯. Thanks

Added some designs and bullet points to the task’s description @JTannerWMF @Dbrant. Disclaimer: this is not a whole design concept, just a concept that might help implement this.

I just reviewed this and think the side panel design, which is reduced to showing the title of the talk page and listing topics, is exactly what it needs to be. Enhanced functionality, like search, amount of replies per topic, and last comment per topic, is available on the detail screen.

How does this look? I have applied the correct color group to icons and text.

This is great, @cooltey — you got them all!

Thanks @cooltey — I can’t test the rollback button – maybe @Dbrant can check if it’s working correctly?

looks good to me – thanks @cooltey

In T308759#7970302, @scblr wrote:

Looks pretty good to me, @cooltey 👏 — I think let’s get the approval of legal first before we invest time in fine-tuning it. CC: @JTannerWMF @LGoto as we might want to discuss this in the planning meeting tonight (added it to the agenda).

In T308750#7974706, @Dbrant wrote:

here is the prototype: https://github.com/wikimedia/apps-android-wikipedia/actions/runs/2417951634

In T308750#7974179, @JTannerWMF wrote:

@scblr , thanks for these considerations. Dmitry showed me the Variant C bottom in the emulator and it works really well, so we will go with that one.

Should we introduce the same input dialog for the rollback button as we currently do for the undo button?

This looks ideal to me @Dbrant 👏

I added Variant C: Bottom to T308750#7961162. Variant C: Top is almost identical but works better IMO, because:

I'm not sure I understand how this would help this situation - doesn't that link compare two versions, and this situation is talking about when there is only one version of the page?

Looks pretty good to me, @cooltey 👏 — I think let’s get the approval of legal first before we invest time in fine-tuning it. CC: @JTannerWMF @LGoto as we might want to discuss this in the planning meeting tonight (added it to the agenda).

@JTannerWMF added Variant C (aka A1) per our discussion yesterday (T308750#7961162) — check it out!

User feedback on Google Play from May 29, 2022:

User feedback by email on May 30, 2022:

User feedback by email on May 26, 2022:

User feedback by email on May 23, 2022:

Ok, here are the new variants, based on the discussion in today’s meeting @JTannerWMF @Dbrant:

• Can we think about how these variants will behave when the user has already entered some search text (i.e. when we're already displaying search results based on the current query)? The UX should still allow the user to switch between different namespaces for the currently-entered search term. It's not clear how variants A, C, or D would behave in such a case.

I timeboxed this to ~ 2 hours and explored a few directions. This is how the “empty state” of the search looks currently:

In T308755#7950096, @Dbrant wrote:

@scblr What are the correct icons that should be used here? The possible types of contributions include (but not limited to):

• Regular articles

01) Per our previous discussion on slack, please add a find in page shortcut here 👇

All looks good to me now @cooltey — thanks!

Example of how it could be handled (blue/green for all additions):

02) Can we add the talk page title/subject, to the view after tapping + NEW TOPIC and REPLY for context?

New topic:	Add talk page name

Reply	Add talk page subject

01) To me it’s a bit unclear why certain topics are displayed when performing a search, see the example below where the search term toc is likely part of a reply in subjects listed as a search result:

@JTannerWMF done ✅