It seems like the title description does not adapt to the user’s font size setting?
Mon, Aug 19
Looks good @cooltey, moving it to QA signoff!
Fri, Aug 16
Hi @cooltey, reducing font size to 12sp below a certain resolution is a passable way to solve this. At which resolution (breakpoint) would you apply it? I estimate that we should apply 12sp below 360dp. In CSS, that would look like this:
Thu, Aug 15
Wed, Aug 14
Yes @Charlotte, let’s arrange them in a 2x2 grid when space is not sufficient (e.g. below a viewport width of 360px):
As discussed on Slack, @cooltey will apply the letter-spacing value of Widget.MaterialComponents.Button to Widget.AppCompat.Button.Borderless 🎯
Hey @cooltey, thanks for mentioning this. Quick question, are we currently using Roboto Medium 14sp with a letter-spacing value of 0.5sp for the buttons? If yes, let’s keep it like that! Thanks!
Mon, Aug 12
I think we found a good solution for this! Thanks @cooltey for leading the efforts.
Hey @Jhernandez, thanks for the additional infos, these are very helpful. We’re performing a user questionnaire at Wikimania this week and are trying to find out which metrics could be motivational for users. Will keep you posted about it!
Great @cooltey, I noticed three discrepancies:
Fri, Aug 9
Thanks for investigating and for rounding it up so comprehensible @JoeWalsh. May I ask for clarification about:
Thanks @Dbrant, just tried it out, works perfectly now!
Thu, Aug 8
Updated the icons on Google Play! 👍
Wed, Aug 7
hey @cooltey, just had a look at the four places you mentioned, looks good! moving it to qa signoff...
Hey @cooltey – do I understand correctly that all images in an article would still be tappable (to get to the gallery view) and it would just not be possible to go left and right from any particular article image? From my perspective, that behavior is fine.
Tue, Aug 6
thanks @cooltey, will review this as soon as there’s no 404 anymore when trying to download the alpha:
Mon, Aug 5
hey @cooltey, can you point me to the situation where this is occurring in the app? thx!
Hey @Jdrewniak, may I ask what the status of this task is? Thanks for letting us know.
Tue, Jul 30
Hey @Sharvaniharan, 02) looks good to me!
Mon, Jul 29
Issues mentioned in T224728#5374101 are fixed, but noticed new ones:
01) Where does the talk page icon come from? Is it Apple specific? There are “chat bubble” icons in Material Design as well, maybe we can use them on Android.
It's the OOUI icon for 'speech bubbles' so if possible I think it'd be great to use it on both platforms for consistency: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/OOUI_icons#speechBubbles. I believe this is the icon currently being used on Android. Technically we could use the 'UserTalk' OOUI icon, but it is often more closely associated with and used for 'Thanks', so I'd prefer to use the chat bubbles if you're okay with that too.
Hey @cooltey @Sharvaniharan, the aforementioned issues are fixed, thanks for that. Unfortunately I observed the issues below. Sorry for being so pedantic about this but since exposure is so high for this (~ 200k logged in users per day will see it) it needs to work perfectly:
Sun, Jul 28
Just tried it out in 2.7.50285-alpha-2019-07-26, looks good @cooltey, moving it to QA signoff! 👏
Fri, Jul 26
Just updated the app via...
Thu, Jul 25
Thanks @cooltey, changed the task’s title. To re-emphasize:
Awesome improvements @cmadeo 👏 Five things I noticed/questions:
Wed, Jul 24
For the sake of completion, here’s the Google Doc with our discussion/next steps in this matter:
Moving this to “Ready for dev” as Design work is done. All details can be found here: T224480#5246870.
Ok, updated the screens and moving this to “Ready for dev”:
+1 to Charlotte’s comment and the solution you suggested sounds good @cooltey:
@cooltey, thought I’ll recap in regards to:
Tue, Jul 23
Good to know @cooltey! How do you currently handle video files in the article? Ideally, videos would also be downloaded in a low resolution. If not feasible, I think it’s fine to output the placeholder image of the video without play button in the gallery for now.
D'oh, my bad 🤦♀️ TMW you don’t know the app you’re working on 24/7: I oddly believed that the gallery features additional images that aren’t used in the article.
Thanks @cmadeo, looks good at first sight! Just as a general note; I assume that 02) 03) 04) and 05) result in a decent amount of design/dev work, at least on Android. Mainly because the proposed solutions are not existing yet. Shouldn’t be a blocker though, just so we’re aware. Additional comments below.
Thanks @Dbrant for pointing us to this. Mainly agree with @Charlotte’s previous assessment with one addition: all images that are visible in the article (inline) should also be available offline (in the higher resolution) in gallery view. I recommend to disable swiping left and right in gallery view when users are offline (instead of showing an error like this):
To refresh my memory, I thought about the reasons why we’re removing the “Nearby” feature in the first place. Also, I think it’ll be crucial to communicate this change as transparent and clearly as possible to the community:
Thanks @Sharvaniharan, the previous issues have been fixed. Looks wonderful! Unfortunately I noticed other issues 🙈:
Jul 22 2019
Thanks @Bencemac & @Roy17 for the valuable feedback. I suggest to go with Google Material Design’s foreseen element to help improve the current situation, which is an assistive element in the form of Helper text:
Jul 19 2019
It works as intended, great job @Sharvaniharan. I know we discussed parts of this on Slack but adding it here for documentation purposes:
Jul 18 2019
Thanks @cooltey, looking forward to these improvements. I’m definitely advocating to treat this as more than just “Low“ priority as accessibility is a core requirement for our products:
Jul 17 2019
I agree @Charlotte, the effects of it are going to be interesting. Let’s try it out and honestly, we can remove the CTA again if we notice high revert rates or if it’s generally perceived in a negative way.
Thanks @Sharvaniharan, looking forward to see the updated version!
Jul 16 2019
Not quite sure why this hasn’t been moved to Design signoff first as there are obviously issues with it @Sharvaniharan ?
Jul 8 2019
Hey @cooltey, quickly checked the remaining issues (20, 30, 30c, 36, 37) after a good night eating dinner with my family in Bella Italia 🇮🇹. Moving this to QA signoff. Thanks for the hard work & have a great week!