Change Details

# TL;DR / action item - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. # Participants Tested with 5 random Android participants from India with the latest Wikipedia Alpha 2.7.50309-alpha-2020-03-17. Check out the “[Add image tags on Android“ session usertesting.com](https://app.usertesting.com/dashboard#!/study/2985933/sessions). # Legend 👍= Works well 👎= Not working well ❓= Not sure if good or bad 🗣= Participant suggests this 💥= Robin’s assessment # Summary / action items - 👍5/5 were zooming the suggested images naturally by pinching without being asked to do so. - 👍5/5 mentioned that the onboarding is pretty clear and they were able to correctly rephrase it in their own words. - 👍4/5 use both “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. Interestengly in no particular order, sometimes they tap “Add tag“ first sometimes they go with the computer suggested ones - 💥It does not matter much where “Add tag“ is positioned. Users approach it with no particular process in mind (in contrary to our internal view). They go back and forth between adding computer aided tags and custom tags. The current interface doesn’t stand it the way to do that and works perfectly. No action item needed - 👍3/5 used image description at the top to add tags with the “Add tag“ functionality. - 💥Image description adds value in most cases, exactly how we intended it. No action item needed. - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. Action item! - 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“ - 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection? - ❓2/5 asked for thinking about hashtags (#), as they’re used on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram or Facebook. - 💥Might be worth to include the notion of a hashtag into designs at some point # Usability tests ## mrvig (a crazy fast typer) 👍Zoom’s image as the first action, has no issues with it. 👍Had a good experience, “it’s really easy!” 👍Interface is pretty clear to him. 👍Swipes to next image without an issue. 👍Add’s a custom tag right away. 👎Completely ignores the computer suggested tags at first and thinks they’re already added to the image (doesn’t tap it) 👎Not sure if he has to publish the images. 👎Doesn’t use description at the top. ❓Wants to use #hashtag ❓Thinks that the search behind “Add tag“ lists computer suggested tags. ❓Adds generic tags with the custom tags feature. 🗣Suggests that users should be able to create their own tags (and not choose from a list) ## user4875 👍Thinks the onboarding dialog is easy to understand, everything is clear. 👍Has no issues zooming an image. 👍Uses “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. The first thing he tapped on is “Add tags“. 👎Does not tap on “Publish“ for almost all images. Swipes right after tapping on a tag. 🗣Likes to have custom hashtags. ## NoxDRaz 👍Uses the interface perfectly (add tags and suggested tags). 👍Sees computer aided tags first 👍Uses “Add tags“ right away. 👍Uses “Publish“ right away. 👍Uses description at the top to add tags. 👍Pinches to zoom perfectly 👎“Add tag“ search does not work half of the time (connection?) 👎Publishing tags feature doesn’t work (connection?) 👎“This Alpha version is pretty bad“ (connection?) 🗣Feature does not work properly. Internet connection issues? “Save has failed“ error message all the time. ## **Di4barfi** 👍Generally understands the onboarding dialog. Even mentions AI supported image tagging. 👍Intuitively zooms images. 👍Uses computer suggested tags first. Order of CAT / custom does not matter. 👍Seamlessly understands how to add suggested and custom tags. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👎Has issues with horizontal scrolling of tags. Suggests to increase the horizontal scroll height. ❓Sometimes doesn’t find tags (types in too specific terms). ## soh78 👍It’s fun adding tags! 👍Understands onboarding dialog. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👍Uses “Add tags“ functionality first. 👍Uses computer aided tags too. 👍Hits Publish and expects to see the next image. 👍Zoom works perfectly. 👎Has some issues with horizontal scroll, suggests to make to horizontal scroll height bigger. 👎Publish error (Code 503), sometimes. 🗣Bigger image. ❓Reads the onboarding dialog and thinks of hashtags (#, like the ones Twitter, Instagram, Facebook)

# TL;DR / action items - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“ - 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection? # Participants Tested with 5 random Android participants from India with the latest Wikipedia Alpha 2.7.50309-alpha-2020-03-17. Check out the “[Add image tags on Android“ session usertesting.com](https://app.usertesting.com/dashboard#!/study/2985933/sessions). # Legend 👍= Works well 👎= Not working well ❓= Not sure if good or bad 🗣= Participant suggests this 💥= Robin’s assessment # Summary / action items - 👍5/5 were zooming the suggested images naturally by pinching without being asked to do so. - 👍5/5 mentioned that the onboarding is pretty clear and they were able to correctly rephrase it in their own words. - 👍4/5 use both “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. Interestengly in no particular order, sometimes they tap “Add tag“ first sometimes they go with the computer suggested ones - 💥It does not matter much where “Add tag“ is positioned. Users approach it with no particular process in mind (in contrary to our internal view). They go back and forth between adding computer aided tags and custom tags. The current interface doesn’t stand it the way to do that and works perfectly. No action item needed - 👍3/5 used image description at the top to add tags with the “Add tag“ functionality. - 💥Image description adds value in most cases, exactly how we intended it. No action item needed. - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. Action item! - 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“ - 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection? - ❓2/5 asked for thinking about hashtags (#), as they’re used on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram or Facebook. - 💥Might be worth to include the notion of a hashtag into designs at some point # Usability tests ## mrvig (a crazy fast typer) 👍Zoom’s image as the first action, has no issues with it. 👍Had a good experience, “it’s really easy!” 👍Interface is pretty clear to him. 👍Swipes to next image without an issue. 👍Add’s a custom tag right away. 👎Completely ignores the computer suggested tags at first and thinks they’re already added to the image (doesn’t tap it) 👎Not sure if he has to publish the images. 👎Doesn’t use description at the top. ❓Wants to use #hashtag ❓Thinks that the search behind “Add tag“ lists computer suggested tags. ❓Adds generic tags with the custom tags feature. 🗣Suggests that users should be able to create their own tags (and not choose from a list) ## user4875 👍Thinks the onboarding dialog is easy to understand, everything is clear. 👍Has no issues zooming an image. 👍Uses “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. The first thing he tapped on is “Add tags“. 👎Does not tap on “Publish“ for almost all images. Swipes right after tapping on a tag. 🗣Likes to have custom hashtags. ## NoxDRaz 👍Uses the interface perfectly (add tags and suggested tags). 👍Sees computer aided tags first 👍Uses “Add tags“ right away. 👍Uses “Publish“ right away. 👍Uses description at the top to add tags. 👍Pinches to zoom perfectly 👎“Add tag“ search does not work half of the time (connection?) 👎Publishing tags feature doesn’t work (connection?) 👎“This Alpha version is pretty bad“ (connection?) 🗣Feature does not work properly. Internet connection issues? “Save has failed“ error message all the time. ## **Di4barfi** 👍Generally understands the onboarding dialog. Even mentions AI supported image tagging. 👍Intuitively zooms images. 👍Uses computer suggested tags first. Order of CAT / custom does not matter. 👍Seamlessly understands how to add suggested and custom tags. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👎Has issues with horizontal scrolling of tags. Suggests to increase the horizontal scroll height. ❓Sometimes doesn’t find tags (types in too specific terms). ## soh78 👍It’s fun adding tags! 👍Understands onboarding dialog. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👍Uses “Add tags“ functionality first. 👍Uses computer aided tags too. 👍Hits Publish and expects to see the next image. 👍Zoom works perfectly. 👎Has some issues with horizontal scroll, suggests to make to horizontal scroll height bigger. 👎Publish error (Code 503), sometimes. 🗣Bigger image. ❓Reads the onboarding dialog and thinks of hashtags (#, like the ones Twitter, Instagram, Facebook)

# TL;DR / action items - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“ - 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection? # Participants Tested with 5 random Android participants from India with the latest Wikipedia Alpha 2.7.50309-alpha-2020-03-17. Check out the “[Add image tags on Android“ session usertesting.com](https://app.usertesting.com/dashboard#!/study/2985933/sessions). # Legend 👍= Works well 👎= Not working well ❓= Not sure if good or bad 🗣= Participant suggests this 💥= Robin’s assessment # Summary / action items - 👍5/5 were zooming the suggested images naturally by pinching without being asked to do so. - 👍5/5 mentioned that the onboarding is pretty clear and they were able to correctly rephrase it in their own words. - 👍4/5 use both “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. Interestengly in no particular order, sometimes they tap “Add tag“ first sometimes they go with the computer suggested ones - 💥It does not matter much where “Add tag“ is positioned. Users approach it with no particular process in mind (in contrary to our internal view). They go back and forth between adding computer aided tags and custom tags. The current interface doesn’t stand it the way to do that and works perfectly. No action item needed - 👍3/5 used image description at the top to add tags with the “Add tag“ functionality. - 💥Image description adds value in most cases, exactly how we intended it. No action item needed. - 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing. - 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. Action item! - 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“ - 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection? - ❓2/5 asked for thinking about hashtags (#), as they’re used on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram or Facebook. - 💥Might be worth to include the notion of a hashtag into designs at some point # Usability tests ## mrvig (a crazy fast typer) 👍Zoom’s image as the first action, has no issues with it. 👍Had a good experience, “it’s really easy!” 👍Interface is pretty clear to him. 👍Swipes to next image without an issue. 👍Add’s a custom tag right away. 👎Completely ignores the computer suggested tags at first and thinks they’re already added to the image (doesn’t tap it) 👎Not sure if he has to publish the images. 👎Doesn’t use description at the top. ❓Wants to use #hashtag ❓Thinks that the search behind “Add tag“ lists computer suggested tags. ❓Adds generic tags with the custom tags feature. 🗣Suggests that users should be able to create their own tags (and not choose from a list) ## user4875 👍Thinks the onboarding dialog is easy to understand, everything is clear. 👍Has no issues zooming an image. 👍Uses “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. The first thing he tapped on is “Add tags“. 👎Does not tap on “Publish“ for almost all images. Swipes right after tapping on a tag. 🗣Likes to have custom hashtags. ## NoxDRaz 👍Uses the interface perfectly (add tags and suggested tags). 👍Sees computer aided tags first 👍Uses “Add tags“ right away. 👍Uses “Publish“ right away. 👍Uses description at the top to add tags. 👍Pinches to zoom perfectly 👎“Add tag“ search does not work half of the time (connection?) 👎Publishing tags feature doesn’t work (connection?) 👎“This Alpha version is pretty bad“ (connection?) 🗣Feature does not work properly. Internet connection issues? “Save has failed“ error message all the time. ## **Di4barfi** 👍Generally understands the onboarding dialog. Even mentions AI supported image tagging. 👍Intuitively zooms images. 👍Uses computer suggested tags first. Order of CAT / custom does not matter. 👍Seamlessly understands how to add suggested and custom tags. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👎Has issues with horizontal scrolling of tags. Suggests to increase the horizontal scroll height. ❓Sometimes doesn’t find tags (types in too specific terms). ## soh78 👍It’s fun adding tags! 👍Understands onboarding dialog. 👍Uses description to add tags. 👍Uses “Add tags“ functionality first. 👍Uses computer aided tags too. 👍Hits Publish and expects to see the next image. 👍Zoom works perfectly. 👎Has some issues with horizontal scroll, suggests to make to horizontal scroll height bigger. 👎Publish error (Code 503), sometimes. 🗣Bigger image. ❓Reads the onboarding dialog and thinks of hashtags (#, like the ones Twitter, Instagram, Facebook)