This question is inspired by @Encycloon at https://nl.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Overleg_Wikipedia:Arbitragecommissie/Zaken/Obama_Nick_Gur&diff=56008041&oldid=56008026
When the handling of edit conflicts on busy pages is good, editors can Reply without even noticing that someone else had just replied to the same comment. Should we notify them when this happens? Would it be possible to differentiate between a relevant edit conflict (same conversation) and edit conflicts elsewhere on the page?
=== Approaches
//This section contains an in-progress list of potential approaches to addressing the need(s) this ticket is "asking" to be met.//
1. **Re-use MediaWiki's existing edit conflict detection mechanism**
-- //Volunteer Experience//
--- i. Someone clicks/taps the {nav Reply} button within the Reply Tool
--- ii. Edit conflict detection mechanism checks whether the page's state has changed in the time between this moment and when the person opened the Reply Tool in "i."
--- iii. If the edit conflict mechanism detects a change, a warning will appear within the Reply Tool informing people that an edit conflict could result from proceeding to publish the comment they drafted
-- //Considerations//
--- There are likely to be many false positives with this approach considering the existing edit conflict detection mechanism does not consider what part of the page might've changed.
-- //Complexity//
--- Relatively straightforward considering we'd be re-using and integrating existing functionality
2. **Introduce a new, more targeted, edit conflict detection mechanism**
-- //Volunteer Experience//
--- i. Someone clicks/taps the {nav Reply} button within the Reply Tool
--- ii. The "new, more targeted" edit conflict detection mechanism begins checking for changes in the state of the section in which the person is drafting a comment within
--- iii. If the "new, more targeted" edit conflict mechanism detects a change, a warning will appear within the Reply Tool informing people that proceeding to publish the comment they are drafting will result in an edit conflict
-- //Considerations//
--- What happens if/when the comment to which you are directly replying to in "i." gets deleted?
--- How confident can the software be that an edit conflict //will// result from the person proceeding to publish they are drafting?
-- //Complexity//
--- More complex considering we'd be introducing a new mechanism that "bounds" detection to the specific section someone is posting a comment to/within