Change Details

T249293 is about hiding reply links on the entire page, this task is about hiding reply links in specific sections. There are two categories of things we want to hide reply links one: 1. Things that are comments, but we don't want people to reply to any more (e.g. closed/archived discussion) 2. Things are have signatures but aren't comments (e.g. vote/participation lists) These should be dealt with slightly differently as in (1) we still want to comment parser to detect them, e.g. for permalinking or computing thread metadata (# of comments in a thread). In (2) we don't want the parser to recognise the comments at all. === Approaches * Define wrapper classes for (1) and (2) which result in reply links being suppressed / signatures being skipped. === Use cases - **cs.wiki** -- AfD discussions (type 1) --- E.g. https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedie:Diskuse_o_smaz%C3%A1n%C3%AD/Hana_Krampolov%C3%A1, as noted by @Urbanecm in T260066. - **fi.wiki** -- Partially archived pages (read: pages that contain at least one section that has been archived using the [ArkistoituOsa](https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malline:Arkistoitu_osa) template) (type 1) --- E.g. https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keskustelu:Havaiji via @Zache in T249293#6652526 -- Votes (type 2) --- E.g.: https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Poisto%C3%A4%C3%A4nestykset/Lydia_Yl%C3%B6stalo as noted by @Zache in T265446#6582035 - **hu.wiki** -- WikiProject member lists (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orH via @Samat in T249293#6654315 - **meta.wiki** -- Attendance planning (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orG as noted by @gh87 in [Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p](https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p) - **frwiki** -- Deletion discussions have threaded discussion in one section, and votes in another ([[ https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discussion:Club_de_cin%C3%A9ma_non_commercial_de_Lorraine/Suppression | example ]])

T249293 is about hiding reply links on the entire page, this task is about hiding reply links in specific sections. There are two categories of things we want to hide reply links one: 1. Things that are comments, but we don't want people to reply to any more (e.g. closed/archived discussion) 2. Things are have signatures but aren't comments (e.g. vote/participation lists) These should be dealt with slightly differently as in (1) we still want to comment parser to detect them, e.g. for permalinking or computing thread metadata (# of comments in a thread). In (2) we don't want the parser to recognise the comments at all. === Approaches * Define wrapper classes for (1) and (2) which result in reply links being suppressed / signatures being skipped. === Use cases - **cs.wiki** -- AfD discussions (type 1) --- E.g. https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedie:Diskuse_o_smaz%C3%A1n%C3%AD/Hana_Krampolov%C3%A1, as noted by @Urbanecm in T260066. - **fi.wiki** -- Partially archived pages (read: pages that contain at least one section that has been archived using the [ArkistoituOsa](https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malline:Arkistoitu_osa) template) (type 1) --- E.g. https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keskustelu:Havaiji via @Zache in T249293#6652526 -- Votes (type 2) --- E.g.: https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Poisto%C3%A4%C3%A4nestykset/Lydia_Yl%C3%B6stalo as noted by @Zache in T265446#6582035 - **hu.wiki** -- WikiProject member lists (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orH via @Samat in T249293#6654315 - **meta.wiki** -- Attendance planning (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orG as noted by @gh87 in [Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p](https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p) -- Community wishlist survery --- https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Community_Wishlist_Survey_2022/Editing --- Proposals are signed in the "Proposer:" section, but that signature does not indicate the text preceding it is a comment. - **frwiki** -- Deletion discussions have threaded discussion in one section, and votes in another ([[ https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discussion:Club_de_cin%C3%A9ma_non_commercial_de_Lorraine/Suppression | example ]])

T249293 is about hiding reply links on the entire page, this task is about hiding reply links in specific sections. There are two categories of things we want to hide reply links one: 1. Things that are comments, but we don't want people to reply to any more (e.g. closed/archived discussion) 2. Things are have signatures but aren't comments (e.g. vote/participation lists) These should be dealt with slightly differently as in (1) we still want to comment parser to detect them, e.g. for permalinking or computing thread metadata (# of comments in a thread). In (2) we don't want the parser to recognise the comments at all. === Approaches * Define wrapper classes for (1) and (2) which result in reply links being suppressed / signatures being skipped. === Use cases - **cs.wiki** -- AfD discussions (type 1) --- E.g. https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedie:Diskuse_o_smaz%C3%A1n%C3%AD/Hana_Krampolov%C3%A1, as noted by @Urbanecm in T260066. - **fi.wiki** -- Partially archived pages (read: pages that contain at least one section that has been archived using the [ArkistoituOsa](https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malline:Arkistoitu_osa) template) (type 1) --- E.g. https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keskustelu:Havaiji via @Zache in T249293#6652526 -- Votes (type 2) --- E.g.: https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Poisto%C3%A4%C3%A4nestykset/Lydia_Yl%C3%B6stalo as noted by @Zache in T265446#6582035 - **hu.wiki** -- WikiProject member lists (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orH via @Samat in T249293#6654315 - **meta.wiki** -- Attendance planning (type 2) --- E.g. https://w.wiki/orG as noted by @gh87 in [Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p](https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Vwp4f1xvzrco195p) -- Community wishlist survery --- https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Community_Wishlist_Survey_2022/Editing --- Proposals are signed in the "Proposer:" section, but that signature does not indicate the text preceding it is a comment. - **frwiki** -- Deletion discussions have threaded discussion in one section, and votes in another ([[ https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discussion:Club_de_cin%C3%A9ma_non_commercial_de_Lorraine/Suppression | example ]])