Change Details

I have a report from a user that [[commons:File:Chiesetta_a_Fénis_1.JPG]] and [[commons:File:Castello_Jocteau_5.JPG]] were actually two images each (for unknown reasons), but uploading a reverted (non-current) version under a new title failed, presumably being considered a reupload/duplicate by unauthorised user. When I tried with the UW I got an unknown error in the first step but normal upload worked: [[commons:File:Chiesetta a Fénis 2.JPG]], [[commons:File:Castello_Jocteau_7.JPG]]. Note that reverting the file to the first version resulted in the first file in file history being lost: related to bug 39615 comment 5? Another byproduct of bug 39221? In summary: 1) Upload two files A and B 2) Expect they are uploaded as files A and B 3) Find that A is uploaded as A, then B is uploaded with A's title (as a new version) 4) Try to upload A under a non-A title (or B with its own title after reverting A's title to A file) 5) Find that you can't upload the file, or history gets lost in the process, or both -------------------------- **Version**: master **Severity**: major **URL**: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Bar_italiano&oldid=78411173#Ho_salvato_due_file_con_lo_stesso_nome

I have a report from a user that https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chiesetta_a_Fénis_1.JPG and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Castello_Jocteau_5.JPG were actually two images each (for unknown reasons), but uploading a reverted (non-current) version under a new title failed, presumably being considered a reupload/duplicate by unauthorised user. When I tried with the UW I got an unknown error in the first step but normal upload worked: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chiesetta a Fénis 2.JPG, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Castello_Jocteau_7.JPG . Note that reverting the file to the first version resulted in the first file in file history being lost: related to T41615 comment 5? Another byproduct of bug T41221? In summary: 1) Upload two files A and B 2) Expect they are uploaded as files A and B 3) Find that A is uploaded as A, then B is uploaded with A's title (as a new version) 4) Try to upload A under a non-A title (or B with its own title after reverting A's title to A file) 5) Find that you can't upload the file, or history gets lost in the process, or both -------------------------- **Version**: master **Severity**: major **URL**: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Bar_italiano&oldid=78411173#Ho_salvato_due_file_con_lo_stesso_nome

I have a report from a user that [[commons:File:Chiesetta_a_Fénis_1.JPG]] and [[commons:File:Castello_Jocteau_5.JPG]]https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chiesetta_a_Fénis_1.JPG and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Castello_Jocteau_5.JPG were actually two images each (for unknown reasons), but uploading a reverted (non-current) version under a new title failed, presumably being considered a reupload/duplicate by unauthorised user. When I tried with the UW I got an unknown error in the first step but normal upload worked: [[https://commons:.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chiesetta a Fénis 2.JPG]], [[https://commons:.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Castello_Jocteau_7.JPG]] . Note that reverting the file to the first version resulted in the first file in file history being lost: related to bug 39T41615 comment 5? Another byproduct of bug 39221T41221? In summary: 1) Upload two files A and B 2) Expect they are uploaded as files A and B 3) Find that A is uploaded as A, then B is uploaded with A's title (as a new version) 4) Try to upload A under a non-A title (or B with its own title after reverting A's title to A file) 5) Find that you can't upload the file, or history gets lost in the process, or both -------------------------- **Version**: master **Severity**: major **URL**: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Bar_italiano&oldid=78411173#Ho_salvato_due_file_con_lo_stesso_nome