Change Details

When tagging an article with Page Curation, you have the option to 'add a message to creator'. It has been suggested that these messages should **//also //**be added to the talk page in a new section with a canned message such as: //**"A New Page Reviewer has left feedback for the creator of this article. The following extract may also be of relevance to other editors in improving this page: (Message to creator here)"**// This would avoid issues where the context for tags isn't recorded on the talk page, or where the creator of a later-expanded redirect is accidentally sent the message instead of the content creator. Requested here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Page_Curation/Suggested_improvements#54._Send_feedback_to_talk_page See task T207452 as an extension of this talk page system.

=== Value proposition When tagging an article with Page Curation, you have the option to 'add a message to creator'. It has been suggested that these messages should also be added to the talk page in a new section. This would ensure that reviewers are able to see context for tags present on the page and also be able to follow-up on comments made by past reviewers. === Risk There is a possible risk of the conversation being fragmented because of the same message being in two places instead of one. The [reviewers agree](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Community_Tech/Page_Curation_and_New_Pages_Feed_improvements) on this not being a big problem. === Required changes: [] Change //Add a message for the creator (optional):// to instead be **//Add a message for the creator. This message will also be posted to the article talk page//**. {F29342540} [] Replace the placeholder in the input box with: //Write a helpful note for $username and future reviewers.// [] When a user adds a comment in the input box and submits it, the message is posted to both the creator's talk page and the article's talk page. [] For the article talk page message: ** **Section heading:** //Feedback from New Page review process// ** **Message**: //I left the following feedback for the creator/future reviewers while reviewing this article: $message. -- Signed by $reviewer// ** !!Question: Can this be a community-controlled template?!! [] If a new reviewer comes along and leaves another message, the message gets added to the same section if the section already exists. Otherwise a new section is created. === Notes: * Requested here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Page_Curation/Suggested_improvements#54._Send_feedback_to_talk_page * Discussion: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Community_Tech/Page_Curation_and_New_Pages_Feed_improvements

=== Value proposition When tagging an article with Page Curation, you have the option to 'add a message to creator'. It has been suggested that these messages should **//also //**be added to the talk page in a new section with a canned message such as: //**"A New Page Reviewer has left feedback for the creator of this articleyou have the option to 'add a message to creator'. The following extract may also be of relevance to other editors in improving this page: (Message to creator here)"**// This would avoid issues where the context for tags isn't recorded on the talk page,It has been suggested that these messages should also be added to the talk page in a new section. or where the creator of a later-expanded redirect is accidentally sent the message instead of the content creatorThis would ensure that reviewers are able to see context for tags present on the page and also be able to follow-up on comments made by past reviewers. === Risk There is a possible risk of the conversation being fragmented because of the same message being in two places instead of one. The [reviewers agree](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Community_Tech/Page_Curation_and_New_Pages_Feed_improvements) on this not being a big problem. === Required changes: [] Change //Add a message for the creator (optional):// to instead be **//Add a message for the creator. This message will also be posted to the article talk page//**. {F29342540} [] Replace the placeholder in the input box with: //Write a helpful note for $username and future reviewers.// [] When a user adds a comment in the input box and submits it, the message is posted to both the creator's talk page and the article's talk page. [] For the article talk page message: ** **Section heading:** //Feedback from New Page review process// ** **Message**: //I left the following feedback for the creator/future reviewers while reviewing this article: $message. -- Signed by $reviewer// ** !!Question: Can this be a community-controlled template?!! [] If a new reviewer comes along and leaves another message, the message gets added to the same section if the section already exists. Otherwise a new section is created. === Notes: * Requested here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Page_Curation/Suggested_improvements#54._Send_feedback_to_talk_page See task T207452 as an extension of this talk page system.* Discussion: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Community_Tech/Page_Curation_and_New_Pages_Feed_improvements