Page MenuHomePhabricator

Add a feature to allow searching and importing/copying content from sister projects
Open, LowestPublic

Description

Noé describes it well here.
The TL;DR is, make something ("Insert Quote/Attestation") similar to the Insert Media dialog, which looks for a certain word/sentence on sister projects like Wikisource, Wikiquote etc., allows to select the snippet where the word/sentence was found, and to have it added to the article as an quote/attestation of use with a link to the whole source document.

Was also suggested during Community Wishlist Survey 2017 and ends up with 32 supports vote.

Event Timeline

Adding Dan and Erik who may have some thoughts!

Yes, this would be great, doing a manual search on Wikisource + copy/paste is very awkward.

For inspiration, there's already a gadget called Quiet Quentin which uses Google Books as citation source. But Wikisource/Wikiquote (maybe with bidirectional linking) would make a lot more sense – the content is directly linkable and the full text is always available.

debt subscribed.

I'm not sure what the Discovery search team can help with at this point, removing search backlog tag.

Noe renamed this task from Add something to allow searching and importing content from sister projects to Add a feature to allow searching and copying content from sister projects.Dec 15 2017, 11:27 PM
Noe updated the task description. (Show Details)
Noe updated the task description. (Show Details)

@Noe You have just changed the context of the request and I believe that it no longer reflects the initial desire. One would hope that the best solution is directly link and the text as it is at the wiki, ie. a translcusion, or transclusion-like.

If this is a new community desire, then it would be worthwhile linking to that change, as it seems to be your wish rather than the community's.

Billinghurst renamed this task from Add a feature to allow searching and copying content from sister projects to Add a feature to allow searching and importing/copying content from sister projects.Dec 17 2017, 1:42 PM
Billinghurst updated the task description. (Show Details)

@Noe You have just changed the context of the request and I believe that it no longer reflects the initial desire. One would hope that the best solution is directly link and the text as it is at the wiki, ie. a translcusion, or transclusion-like.

If this is a new community desire, then it would be worthwhile linking to that change, as it seems to be your wish rather than the community's.

I have tried to add the original context as this was more than a Wiktionary item. There seems to be a couple of ideas on whether it is a copy/paste or a reference/tranclusion approach. Maybe leave that open for further discussion as both certainly have benefits and downsides.

I didn't realized I changed the direction of this idea. It was already clear when it was proposed to the Community Wishlist Survey in 2016: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/2016_Community_Wishlist_Survey/Categories/Wiktionary#CW2016-R097

In my opinion, there is no need for a transclusion, because texts in Wikisource are stables, but, I agree to let this point open for further discussion.