Page MenuHomePhabricator

Make "Restrict orphan tag addition to linkless pages" the default and retire the option to toggle it.
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

On english wikipedia to change the auto wiki browser to remove the function of adding orphan tags to articles that already have at least one valid incoming link ( including lists, but niot disambig or redirects) as this is in contravention of [[WP:Orphan]], thanks

Event Timeline

@Atlantic306, under Options menu, please tick "Restrict orphan tag addition to linkless pages" then report back whether AWB is tagging as expected.

Hi, have only got an ipad at home so haven't been able to check yet but the problem is that the default setting of AWB is to add orphan tags to pages with less than 3 eligible incoming links which is in direct contravention of [[WP:Orphan]] which states that orphan tags should only be added to articles with no eligible links. This was confirmed at a well attended VP discussion on orphans a few months ago. Therefore the AWB should not have the default or an option to add tags to articles with at least one eligible incoming links, thanks Jimmy ( Atlantic306)

Sent from my iPad

CommunityTechBot renamed this task from awb orphans to Orphan Tags.Jul 5 2018, 6:44 PM
CommunityTechBot raised the priority of this task from Low to Needs Triage.
CommunityTechBot updated the task description. (Show Details)

@Atlantic306 I completely agree, at least as far as the English Wikipedia is concerned. I recently did an AWB run, letting it tag three articles as {{Orphan}}. I was quickly reverted as each of those articles already had at least one backlink from article space. Apparently, the guidance for the {{Orphan}} tag (and [[WP:O]], as you mention) changed in recent years from a definition of "fewer than three" to "zero". I was unaware of this change, and AWB's default behavior put me in the wrong. I quickly discovered this checkbox, but have to wonder why it still exists, let alone why it is the default.

Voidxor renamed this task from Orphan Tags to Make "Restrict orphan tag addition to linkless pages" the default and retire the ability to toggle it..Mar 9 2021, 8:39 PM
Voidxor renamed this task from Make "Restrict orphan tag addition to linkless pages" the default and retire the ability to toggle it. to Make "Restrict orphan tag addition to linkless pages" the default and retire the option to toggle it..Mar 9 2021, 8:50 PM

Building on this request, [[Wikipedia:Orphan#Criteria]] states "A single, relevant incoming link is sufficient to remove the tag." Therefore, as part of the request above, could AWB also remove {{orphan}} when there is at least one incoming link from articlespace? Thanks!