Noticed this for ar wiki and hu wiki so far. When I enabled DiscussionTools with the query string parameter
?dtenable=1 on a talk page on these wikis I didn't see any Reply link. After refreshing the page it appeared.
Screenshot:
Ryasmeen | |
Feb 18 2020, 11:23 PM |
F31621787: Screen Shot 2020-02-18 at 3.11.11 PM.png | |
Feb 18 2020, 11:23 PM |
Noticed this for ar wiki and hu wiki so far. When I enabled DiscussionTools with the query string parameter
?dtenable=1 on a talk page on these wikis I didn't see any Reply link. After refreshing the page it appeared.
Screenshot:
Status | Subtype | Assigned | Task | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Open | None | T233443 [Epic] Reply Tool | |||
Resolved | ppelberg | T235923 Replies v1.0: release replying to specific comments | |||
Resolved | ppelberg | T236951 Deploy Replying v1.0 to target wikis | |||
Resolved | Ryasmeen | T244432 Evaluate reliability of #DiscussionTools on target wikis | |||
Resolved | matmarex | T244870 Deploy v1.0 via query string parameter to target wikis | |||
Resolved | matmarex | T243621 Create query string parameter to enable/disable DiscussionTools on target wikis | |||
Invalid | None | T245571 Reply link does not appear on the first time loading DiscussionTools (on hu and ar wiki) | |||
Resolved | matmarex | T245574 After closing the reply box on fr.wiki, there is a blue border showing up on the talk page |
Hi @JTannerWMF, yeah this one is a bit hard to reproduce, I got this error on Chrome and only when I enabled DiscussionTools for the first time. Couldn't reproduce it anymore on the next few attempts. So maybe try to use an account that never enabled DiscussionTools on those wiki before.
Good news (I think?): I tried the above using Chrome and on an account that never enabled DiscussionTools [1] and I was not able to reproduce the issue. Read: Reply links appeared as I expected them to on first load.
Considering the above, I'm going to close this as invalid with the following assumption in mind: checking whether the reply links appear as we expect them to will be part of our routine QA.
Meaning: if this is still an issue, we have a plan in place to detect it.