Page MenuHomePhabricator

Prompt user to create a regular account after temp account creation rate limit trip
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

If a user trips the rate limit for temp account creation (T357777, T342880) for an IP address, we should redirect the user to Special:CreateAccount and provide a UX informing them that they can proceed with their edit if they create an account.

Event Timeline

Note account creation itself is also rate limited and some guide may be provided if the IP can create no more accounts currently.

Maybe just block them?

At the high end (as in more account creation attempts) there are long term vandals/abusers (a.k.a. LTA's), editathons (scheduled mass gatherings of people editing WMF sites) and countries with limited number of IP's versus population (like some African countries - https://afrinic.net/ip-address-and-asn-allocations-in-africa). LTA's are blocked anyway and editathons usually have short ip rate limit exemptions. Also the difference between LTA's and editathons, is that LTA's go through many IP's (sometimes more than 10 per month), editathons do not. I do not know how the whole countries with limited number of IP's goes, I have no experience with it.

Was considering adding logged-out bots to the mix, but they do not frequently clear their cookies or change their IP's. Proxies might be in this list, but there are allready some blocked.

At the low end (as in less account creation attempts) there are schools and libraries. They also do not go through many IP's.

kostajh renamed this task from Prompt user to create an account after rate limit trip to Prompt user to create a regular account after temp account creation rate limit trip.Mar 5 2024, 4:26 PM