Page MenuHomePhabricator

ImageAnnotator gadget: ImageNotes breaking on certain pages
Open, Needs TriagePublicBUG REPORT

Description

I don't have a proper way to replicate this that will work on all PCs, but I'm willing, if possible, to make arrangements for someone to have remote access to my PC if it cannot otherwise be replicated. On some, but not all, pages, the ImageNote capability is effectively broken. I cannot see existing ImageNotes (if any) and the "Add a Note" button is not present. Examples of pages where it fails: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jackson_Street_Regrade,_June_10,_1908_-_DPLA_-_97f4eb554efec498bc282cbabedbb9be.jpg (which has no existing ImageNotes) and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jackson_St_looking_east_from_the_waterfront_(SEATTLE_1815).jpg (which has existing ImageNotes, according to the wikitext). Examples of pages where ImageNote works fine: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jackson_Street_Regrade_from_6th_Ave._S._trestle,_June_10,_1908_-_DPLA_-_e237d739b9936fe1a9dc067a089e515b.jpg and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jackson_Street_Regrade_changes,_ca._1909_-_DPLA_-_16ac94cedcc903ff5f4426fedb27da48_(page_1).jpg.

What happens?: I cannot see existing ImageNotes when I hover, and the "Add a Note" button is not present.

What should have happened instead?: I should be able to view ImageNotes, and the "Add a Note" button should be available.

Software version (skip for WMF-hosted wikis like Wikipedia): N/A: Wikimedia Commons

Other information (browser name/version, screenshots, etc.): Firefox 104.0.2, 64-bit (problem has been consistent over a series of releases, has continued for months) on Windows 10.

Event Timeline

Aklapper renamed this task from ImageNotes breaking on certain pages to ImageAnnotator gadget: ImageNotes breaking on certain pages.Sep 25 2022, 10:59 AM

I have the same issue as Jmabel, but I am able to seemingly always add a note with another account, which I primarily use to add a note with the image annotator on commons.

An example from me: I can see the button and notes at https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vegetation_at_Honningsvag_September_2016.jpg but not at https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SR_Technics_hangar_at_Zurich_International_Airport.jpg although an image note exists there (both the button as well as the note are not displayed).

Here I found an edit by someone with the same issue who provided quite a lot of details of their user profile in the aim of finding a solution. Tools or gadgets they had activated, browser they used etc. are mentioned. The user doesn't seem to be active anymore, though.

I have noticed that in some files such as this one the Image annotator works with the Vector 2010 (Legacy) but not with the Vector 2022. But also in the Vector 2010 (legacy) the image annotator still only works with the described work-around in the pop-up window. ~~~~

Ok, now the image annotator also only works with a work around with the other account which is this one

For some days in the end of January until the 6 February, the Image Annotator worked with the workaround from the Paradise Chronicle account but with my other account it worked only with the workaround. From the 6 February it switched back, and now the image annotator works normal again with the other account but it doesn't work anymore (or only selectively, have yet to find out) at the Paradise Chronicle account.