Page MenuHomePhabricator

Page Licenses/Copyright notices
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Author: davidco

Description:
I know many wiki's seem to be struggling with licenses and copyright and I came up with what I
think is an elegant solution.

On the first edit of an Article, have another text box for "License or Copyright Notice" and a
checkbox for [ ] Public Domain [ ] Copyright. The default would be PD. If the user enters text
into the textbox, the Copyright checkbox is set. On submit, the copyright text gets saved in the
database with the username of the author. This would only be available for logged-in users. All
other Articles would get set as Public Domain.

So then at the top of that page, the license is mentioned at the top of the page saying something
like "This Article is copyrighted. See {link} for details."

Only the original author would be allowed to change the copyright, but the contents would be
editable. In the case of a byline author, all future edits are considered gifts to the byline
author. In the case of a collective license, like one of the Creative Commons licenses, each person
that edits the article is responsible for signing it and agreeing to the license. (If they don't
then they're giving away their rights).

So a MediaWiki wiki could then allow PD and licensed content in a shared environment without any
legal hassles.

Even if someone could write up a list of things that would need to be changed, I could probably
jump into the code myself. Maybe this could be an extenstion or something.


Version: unspecified
Severity: enhancement

Details

Reference
bz1386
TitleReferenceAuthorSource BranchDest Branch
SetupCommand: Pass git clone options only if setkharlan/mediawiki-metal!31kharlanT338614main
Customize query in GitLab

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Lowest.Nov 21 2014, 8:08 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz1386.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

robert_horning wrote:

Some copyright licenses don't "allow" you to change the status in a manner like
this. Article copyright status is more of a Wiki-wide issue anyway, and
something that should be covered as part of the overall Wiki organization.

If, for instance, you change the copyright status of an article from GFDL to
Public Domain, and another author has contributed, you would have to essentially
"go back" and revert to earlier content before the new user made changes. I see
some ugly consequences to allowing a change of this nature, and certainly the
"original" author does not nor should have any precedence to any other
contributor. If they were the "only" author, such a license change might be
permitted legally. Image and media copyright status is a little more flexable,
but is not usually modified by user in the same manner that text on a Wiki is
changed.

davidco wrote:

I actually already modified my version of mediawiki (IFWiki.Org) to implement a License tab. It's
worked fine so far even though only a handful of people have used it. Only the original author has
access to the License tab. If someone were to try to move material in and out of various licenses
and cause problems, we'd just boot their material off the wiki. So far, no problems.

robchur wrote:

Don't see a widespread need for this. As someone commented above, licencing
issues are sorted when the wiki is created. If this is desired, someone can hack
it in or write an extension.