Change Details

=== Usability test Testing script: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sWUs9HFPwR4wP2Tb1h6LM38yNCPYfpgS3o1uz4yiiPI/edit# Clickable prototype: https://wikimedia.invisionapp.com/share/BZTUWXU3E95 ===Testing goals The primary goals of this study are to gain insights on the following aspects of the computer-aided depicts tagging tool: Identify usability improvements the tag review flow Gauge the user’s impression of suggested tags Measure the understanding of the benefits of this feature ===Research questions //First impressions and general understanding of depicts tags// - Are the provided onboarding screens sufficient for understanding this tool? - Can users successfully describe what the difference is between “Uploads” and “Popular images” in the navigation? - What are external users’ first impressions of computer-suggested tags? //Performing key tasks// - Can users perform the task of confirming and rejecting tags? - Can users successfully ignore a tag if they are unsure whether to add it? - Can users successfully undo a confirmed or a rejected tag? - Can users successfully “zoom” in on an image and get back to the tagging tool? - Do they have difficulty performing the overall task? //Gauging general sentiment// - Do users find reviewing tags to be friendly and easy to use? - Is the quality and appropriateness of tags acceptable for users? - Do users feel the need to confirm tags before publishing changes? ----- ===Findings from prototype v1 ====//Onboarding screen// ✅ All users had a correct understanding of the information on the onboarding page ✏️ Two users wondered if they will be able to manually add tags ====//Personal uploads vs popular// ✅ Five users correctly guessed that Personal uploads meant a user’s uploads ✅ Three users correctly guessed that Popular meant uploads by others ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant a brand or popular seller ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant what’s important right now on social media or things that are being currently searched for ====//Tags: first impression// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the ‘X’ of each tag would reject those tags ✅ Three users correctly guessed that they could manually tap a tag for approval ✏️ Two users thought that they’d approve the tags by just publishing them (and rejecting ones they didn’t want) ✏️ Two users wanted to be able to add their own tags and thought that was missing ✏️ One user noted that, based on the onboarding screen mentioning it, that they were expecting an ignore option ❌ One user incorrectly thought that tapping on a tag would show a different suggestion ====//Skipping images// ✅ All users correctly guessed that skipping images would take them to the next image ✅ Three users had no expectation that they’d see a skipped image again ✏️ Two users hoped they would see skipped images either “down the road” or in some “skipped images” area ====//Zooming in and getting more info// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the image would open up the image in a larger view ✅ All users correctly guessed “Details” would take them to a page that gave them media info (size, format, uploader, etc.) ====//Unfamiliar tags// ✏️ Four users would ‘X’ out a tag if they were unfamiliar with it ✏️ One user would google the name of any tag if they were unfamiliar with it ====//Interacting with tags// ✅ All users were able to successfully confirm a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully reject a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully undo a rejected tag ====//Publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what would happen if they were to publish the tags they reviewed ====//Finalizing tags before publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what this screen is for (confirming tags before publishing) ✏️ Two users stated that they would prefer to see the image on the Confirm screen ✏️ One user did not expect this screen and thought it would be sufficient to double-check their own work on the tagging screen ❌ One user didn’t like the layout of this screen as it didn’t fit the previous one ====//Cleared queue// ✅ Four users guessed that tapping Tag popular images would enable them to tag images uploaded by others ✏️ Two users thought it would be good to be prompted to upload more images ✏️ Two users thought it would be useful to see the work they had already done on this screen ✏️ One user hoped that Popular images could suggest similar images to the ones they uploaded, since they would likely be more informed about those particular types of images ✏️ One user thought that this screen needed more color ❌ One user thought popular meant what was trending that week ===Suggested updates ====//Onboarding screen// - Iterate on stand-in graphic ====//Confirmation screen// - Add image to Confirmation screen ====//Cleared queue// - Iterate on stand-in graphic - Include link to user's Uploads page - Consider including link to user's Contributions page - Consider including CTA to upload more images

=== Usability test Testing script: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sWUs9HFPwR4wP2Tb1h6LM38yNCPYfpgS3o1uz4yiiPI/edit# Clickable prototype: https://wikimedia.invisionapp.com/share/BZTUWXU3E95 ===Testing goals The primary goals of this study are to gain insights on the following aspects of the computer-aided depicts tagging tool: Identify usability improvements the tag review flow Gauge the user’s impression of suggested tags Measure the understanding of the benefits of this feature ===Research questions //First impressions and general understanding of depicts tags// - Are the provided onboarding screens sufficient for understanding this tool? - Can users successfully describe what the difference is between “Uploads” and “Popular images” in the navigation? - What are external users’ first impressions of computer-suggested tags? //Performing key tasks// - Can users perform the task of confirming and rejecting tags? - Can users successfully ignore a tag if they are unsure whether to add it? - Can users successfully undo a confirmed or a rejected tag? - Can users successfully “zoom” in on an image and get back to the tagging tool? - Do they have difficulty performing the overall task? //Gauging general sentiment// - Do users find reviewing tags to be friendly and easy to use? - Is the quality and appropriateness of tags acceptable for users? - Do users feel the need to confirm tags before publishing changes? ----- ===Findings from prototype v1 ====//Onboarding screen// ✅ All users had a correct understanding of the information on the onboarding page ✏️ Two users wondered if they will be able to manually add tags ====//Personal uploads vs popular// ✅ Five users correctly guessed that Personal uploads meant a user’s uploads ✅ Three users correctly guessed that Popular meant uploads by others ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant a brand or popular seller ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant what’s important right now on social media or things that are being currently searched for ====//Tags: first impression// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the ‘X’ of each tag would reject those tags ✅ Three users correctly guessed that they could manually tap a tag for approval ✏️ Two users thought that they’d approve the tags by just publishing them (and rejecting ones they didn’t want) ✏️ Two users wanted to be able to add their own tags and thought that was missing ✏️ One user noted that, based on the onboarding screen mentioning it, that they were expecting an ignore option ❌ One user incorrectly thought that tapping on a tag would show a different suggestion ====//Skipping images// ✅ All users correctly guessed that skipping images would take them to the next image ✅ Three users had no expectation that they’d see a skipped image again ✏️ Two users hoped they would see skipped images either “down the road” or in some “skipped images” area ====//Zooming in and getting more info// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the image would open up the image in a larger view ✅ All users correctly guessed “Details” would take them to a page that gave them media info (size, format, uploader, etc.) ====//Unfamiliar tags// ✏️ Four users would ‘X’ out a tag if they were unfamiliar with it ✏️ One user would google the name of any tag if they were unfamiliar with it ====//Interacting with tags// ✅ All users were able to successfully confirm a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully reject a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully undo a rejected tag ====//Publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what would happen if they were to publish the tags they reviewed ====//Finalizing tags before publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what this screen is for (confirming tags before publishing) ✏️ Two users stated that they would prefer to see the image on the Confirm screen ✏️ One user did not expect this screen and thought it would be sufficient to double-check their own work on the tagging screen ❌ One user didn’t like the layout of this screen as it didn’t fit the previous one ====//Cleared queue// ✅ Four users guessed that tapping Tag popular images would enable them to tag images uploaded by others ✏️ Two users thought it would be good to be prompted to upload more images ✏️ Two users thought it would be useful to see the work they had already done on this screen ✏️ One user hoped that Popular images could suggest similar images to the ones they uploaded, since they would likely be more informed about those particular types of images ✏️ One user thought that this screen needed more color ❌ One user thought popular meant what was trending that week ===Suggested updates ====//Onboarding screen// - Iterate on stand-in graphic ====//Tag interaction// - Since users mostly treated unfamiliar tags by rejecting (vs ignoring) them, consider simplifying the interaction to only suggested and confirmed tags. This would mean removing the X's, and tapping on a tag will either confirm it, and tapping a confirmed tag would unconfirm it (making it suggested again) ====//Confirmation screen// - Add image to Confirmation screen - If tag interaction is simplified, include only confirmed tags on this screen ====//Cleared queue// - Iterate on stand-in graphic - Consider one of the following as a secondary CTA: -- link to user's Uploads page -- link to user's Contributions page -- CTA to upload more images

=== Usability test Testing script: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sWUs9HFPwR4wP2Tb1h6LM38yNCPYfpgS3o1uz4yiiPI/edit# Clickable prototype: https://wikimedia.invisionapp.com/share/BZTUWXU3E95 ===Testing goals The primary goals of this study are to gain insights on the following aspects of the computer-aided depicts tagging tool: Identify usability improvements the tag review flow Gauge the user’s impression of suggested tags Measure the understanding of the benefits of this feature ===Research questions //First impressions and general understanding of depicts tags// - Are the provided onboarding screens sufficient for understanding this tool? - Can users successfully describe what the difference is between “Uploads” and “Popular images” in the navigation? - What are external users’ first impressions of computer-suggested tags? //Performing key tasks// - Can users perform the task of confirming and rejecting tags? - Can users successfully ignore a tag if they are unsure whether to add it? - Can users successfully undo a confirmed or a rejected tag? - Can users successfully “zoom” in on an image and get back to the tagging tool? - Do they have difficulty performing the overall task? //Gauging general sentiment// - Do users find reviewing tags to be friendly and easy to use? - Is the quality and appropriateness of tags acceptable for users? - Do users feel the need to confirm tags before publishing changes? ----- ===Findings from prototype v1 ====//Onboarding screen// ✅ All users had a correct understanding of the information on the onboarding page ✏️ Two users wondered if they will be able to manually add tags ====//Personal uploads vs popular// ✅ Five users correctly guessed that Personal uploads meant a user’s uploads ✅ Three users correctly guessed that Popular meant uploads by others ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant a brand or popular seller ❌ One user incorrectly guessed that Popular meant what’s important right now on social media or things that are being currently searched for ====//Tags: first impression// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the ‘X’ of each tag would reject those tags ✅ Three users correctly guessed that they could manually tap a tag for approval ✏️ Two users thought that they’d approve the tags by just publishing them (and rejecting ones they didn’t want) ✏️ Two users wanted to be able to add their own tags and thought that was missing ✏️ One user noted that, based on the onboarding screen mentioning it, that they were expecting an ignore option ❌ One user incorrectly thought that tapping on a tag would show a different suggestion ====//Skipping images// ✅ All users correctly guessed that skipping images would take them to the next image ✅ Three users had no expectation that they’d see a skipped image again ✏️ Two users hoped they would see skipped images either “down the road” or in some “skipped images” area ====//Zooming in and getting more info// ✅ All users correctly guessed that tapping on the image would open up the image in a larger view ✅ All users correctly guessed “Details” would take them to a page that gave them media info (size, format, uploader, etc.) ====//Unfamiliar tags// ✏️ Four users would ‘X’ out a tag if they were unfamiliar with it ✏️ One user would google the name of any tag if they were unfamiliar with it ====//Interacting with tags// ✅ All users were able to successfully confirm a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully reject a tag ✅ All users were able to successfully undo a rejected tag ====//Publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what would happen if they were to publish the tags they reviewed ====//Finalizing tags before publishing// ✅ All users correctly guessed what this screen is for (confirming tags before publishing) ✏️ Two users stated that they would prefer to see the image on the Confirm screen ✏️ One user did not expect this screen and thought it would be sufficient to double-check their own work on the tagging screen ❌ One user didn’t like the layout of this screen as it didn’t fit the previous one ====//Cleared queue// ✅ Four users guessed that tapping Tag popular images would enable them to tag images uploaded by others ✏️ Two users thought it would be good to be prompted to upload more images ✏️ Two users thought it would be useful to see the work they had already done on this screen ✏️ One user hoped that Popular images could suggest similar images to the ones they uploaded, since they would likely be more informed about those particular types of images ✏️ One user thought that this screen needed more color ❌ One user thought popular meant what was trending that week ===Suggested updates ====//Onboarding screen// - Iterate on stand-in graphic ====//Tag interaction// - Since users mostly treated unfamiliar tags by rejecting (vs ignoring) them, consider simplifying the interaction to only suggested and confirmed tags. This would mean removing the X's, and tapping on a tag will either confirm it, and tapping a confirmed tag would unconfirm it (making it suggested again) ====//Confirmation screen// - Add image to Confirmation screen - If tag interaction is simplified, include only confirmed tags on this screen ====//Cleared queue// - Iterate on stand-in graphic - Include- Consider one of the following as a secondary CTA: -- link to user's Uploads page - Consider including-- link to user's Contributions page - Consider including-- CTA to upload more images