Change Details

The following code generates an anchor that goes nowhere: ``` <ref name="TEST%3BTEST">Test</ref> ``` Something like the following code results, which pretty clearly will not function as intended. ``` <a href="#cite_note-TEST;TEST">[1]</a> . . . . <li id="cite_note-TEST%3BTEST"> ``` Normally, you'd just want to avoid percent-encoded symbols in ref names. However, this is a problem on English Wikipedia if you use Harvard citation templates, which programmatically generate reference names, and include a hard link URL in the parameter for page number(s). For example, `{{sfn|Earle|1896|ps=none|pp=[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=%3Bseq=125 89–90]. {{open access}}}}` creates an anchor with the following ID: ``` #cite_note-FOOTNOTEEarle1896[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=&#25;3Bseq=125_89–90]._<span_style="position:relative;_top:_-2px;">[[File:Open_Access_logo_PLoS_transparent.svg|9px|link=Open_access|open_access_publication_–_free_to_read]]</span>-3" ``` One of the maintainers of the template/module series referred me to Phabricator given the problem of percent-encoded symbols in the ref name occurs even without the template. While the situation where this occurred was resolvable by replacing `%3B` with a semicolon (and, later, I found out could have been fixed by using a numerical character reference, i.e., `&3B;`), I suspect there may be situations where it's not so easily remedied, and otherwise strikes me as something buggy, or at least that ought to be documented better. I initially thought this was a duplicate of T183049, but I can't tell if that one was solely dealing with the mobile frontend. Apologies if this should have just been posted as a reply to that report; this is my first time submitting anything!

The following code generates an anchor that goes nowhere: ``` <ref name="TEST%3BTEST">Test</ref> ``` Something like the following code results, which pretty clearly will not function as intended. ``` <a href="#cite_note-TEST;TEST">[1]</a> . . . . <li id="cite_note-TEST%3BTEST"> ``` Normally, you'd just want to avoid percent-encoded symbols in ref names. However, this is a problem on English Wikipedia if you use Harvard citation templates, which programmatically generate reference names, and include a hard link URL in the parameter for page number(s). For example, `{{sfn|Earle|1896|ps=none|pp=[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=%3Bseq=125 89–90]. {{open access}}}}` creates an anchor with the following ID: ``` #cite_note-FOOTNOTEEarle1896[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=&#25;3Bseq=125_89–90]._<span_style="position:relative;_top:_-2px;">[[File:Open_Access_logo_PLoS_transparent.svg|9px|link=Open_access|open_access_publication_–_free_to_read]]</span>-3" ``` One of the maintainers of the template/module series referred me to Phabricator given the problem of percent-encoded symbols in the ref name occurs even without the template. While the situation where this occurred was resolvable by replacing `%3B` with a semicolon (and, later, I found out could have been fixed by using a numerical character reference, i.e., `&#3B;`), I suspect there may be situations where it's not so easily remedied, and otherwise strikes me as something buggy, or at least that ought to be documented better. I initially thought this was a duplicate of T183049, but I can't tell if that one was solely dealing with the mobile frontend. Apologies if this should have just been posted as a reply to that report; this is my first time submitting anything!

The following code generates an anchor that goes nowhere: ``` <ref name="TEST%3BTEST">Test</ref> ``` Something like the following code results, which pretty clearly will not function as intended. ``` <a href="#cite_note-TEST;TEST">[1]</a> . . . . <li id="cite_note-TEST%3BTEST"> ``` Normally, you'd just want to avoid percent-encoded symbols in ref names. However, this is a problem on English Wikipedia if you use Harvard citation templates, which programmatically generate reference names, and include a hard link URL in the parameter for page number(s). For example, `{{sfn|Earle|1896|ps=none|pp=[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=%3Bseq=125 89–90]. {{open access}}}}` creates an anchor with the following ID: ``` #cite_note-FOOTNOTEEarle1896[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/hvd.32044020031191?urlappend=&#25;3Bseq=125_89–90]._<span_style="position:relative;_top:_-2px;">[[File:Open_Access_logo_PLoS_transparent.svg|9px|link=Open_access|open_access_publication_–_free_to_read]]</span>-3" ``` One of the maintainers of the template/module series referred me to Phabricator given the problem of percent-encoded symbols in the ref name occurs even without the template. While the situation where this occurred was resolvable by replacing `%3B` with a semicolon (and, later, I found out could have been fixed by using a numerical character reference, i.e., `&#3B;`), I suspect there may be situations where it's not so easily remedied, and otherwise strikes me as something buggy, or at least that ought to be documented better. I initially thought this was a duplicate of T183049, but I can't tell if that one was solely dealing with the mobile frontend. Apologies if this should have just been posted as a reply to that report; this is my first time submitting anything!