# TL;DR / action items
- 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing.
- 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing.
- 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“
- 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection?
# Participants
Tested with 5 random Android participants from India with the latest Wikipedia Alpha 2.7.50309-alpha-2020-03-17. Check out the “[Add image tags on Android“ session usertesting.com](https://app.usertesting.com/dashboard#!/study/2985933/sessions).
# Legend
👍= Works well
👎= Not working well
❓= Not sure if good or bad
🗣= Participant suggests this
💥= Robin’s assessment
# Summary / action items
- 👍5/5 were zooming the suggested images naturally by pinching without being asked to do so.
- 👍5/5 mentioned that the onboarding is pretty clear and they were able to correctly rephrase it in their own words.
- 👍4/5 use both “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. Interestingly in no particular order, sometimes they tap “Add tag“ first sometimes they go with the computer suggested ones.
- 💥Positioning of “Add tag“ is might not be that important. Users approach it with no particular process in mind (in contrary to our internal view/story). They go back and forth between adding computer aided tags and custom tags. The current interface doesn’t stand it the way – it works. No action item needed.
- 👍3/5 used image description at the top to add tags with the “Add tag“ functionality.
- 💥Image description adds value in most cases, exactly how we intended it. No action item needed.
- 👎4/5 had issues with horizontal scrolling of tags vs swiping through suggestions. One participant used a swipe left to navigate to the next image without publishing.
- 💥Disable swipe gestures completely to make sure people can horizontally scroll tags without issues and are not using swipe gestures to navigate to the next image without publishing. Action item!
- 👎3/5 had issues with publishing of tags (two different errors: “Save has failed“ and “503 Publish Error“
- 💥We probably need to investigate on this? Is the API reliable in areas with slightly slower connection?
- ❓2/5 asked for thinking about hashtags (#), as they’re used on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram or Facebook.
- 💥Might be worth to include the notion of a hashtag into designs at some point
# Usability tests
## mrvig
(a crazy fast typer)
👍Zoom’s image as the first action, has no issues with it.
👍Had a good experience, “it’s really easy!”
👍Interface is pretty clear to him.
👍Swipes to next image without an issue.
👍Add’s a custom tag right away.
👎Completely ignores the computer suggested tags at first and thinks they’re already added to the image (doesn’t tap it)
👎Not sure if he has to publish the images.
👎Doesn’t use description at the top.
❓Wants to use #hashtag
❓Thinks that the search behind “Add tag“ lists computer suggested tags.
❓Adds generic tags with the custom tags feature.
🗣Suggests that users should be able to create their own tags (and not choose from a list)
## user4875
👍Thinks the onboarding dialog is easy to understand, everything is clear.
👍Has no issues zooming an image.
👍Uses “Add tags“ and computer suggested tags. The first thing he tapped on is “Add tags“.
👎Does not tap on “Publish“ for almost all images. Swipes right after tapping on a tag.
🗣Likes to have custom hashtags.
## NoxDRaz
👍Uses the interface perfectly (add tags and suggested tags).
👍Sees computer aided tags first
👍Uses “Add tags“ right away.
👍Uses “Publish“ right away.
👍Uses description at the top to add tags.
👍Pinches to zoom perfectly
👎“Add tag“ search does not work half of the time (connection?)
👎Publishing tags feature doesn’t work (connection?)
👎“This Alpha version is pretty bad“ (connection?)
🗣Feature does not work properly. Internet connection issues? “Save has failed“ error message all the time.
## **Di4barfi**
👍Generally understands the onboarding dialog. Even mentions AI supported image tagging.
👍Intuitively zooms images.
👍Uses computer suggested tags first. Order of CAT / custom does not matter.
👍Seamlessly understands how to add suggested and custom tags.
👍Uses description to add tags.
👎Has issues with horizontal scrolling of tags. Suggests to increase the horizontal scroll height.
❓Sometimes doesn’t find tags (types in too specific terms).
## soh78
👍It’s fun adding tags!
👍Understands onboarding dialog.
👍Uses description to add tags.
👍Uses “Add tags“ functionality first.
👍Uses computer aided tags too.
👍Hits Publish and expects to see the next image.
👍Zoom works perfectly.
👎Has some issues with horizontal scroll, suggests to make to horizontal scroll height bigger.
👎Publish error (Code 503), sometimes.
🗣Bigger image.
❓Reads the onboarding dialog and thinks of hashtags (#, like the ones Twitter, Instagram, Facebook)