Page MenuHomePhabricator

Special:Whatlinkshere does not list transcluded template links
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Author: jerryopennap

Description:
An example:
A user creates the article [[The Foo]], and it becomes so large that the article becomes split up into several subarticles, including [[History of Foo]], [[Modern Foo]], and [[Foo in Fiction]]. On each subarticle, [[Template:Main]] is translcuded by adding the {{Main|The Foo}}, which reproduces "Main Article: [[The Foo|]]".

Another editor recognizes that [[The Foo]] is not compliant with the manual of style, in that it has a superfluous "The" in the page name, and he want to fix this by moving the article to [[Foo]]. Prior to doing this, the diligent editor checks [[Special:Whatlinkshere/The_Foo]], to determine if any links need to be updated in the process, to prevent double-redirects. He is told "No pages in the English Wikipedia link to [[The Foo]]", and proceeds with the page move.

The result is several double-redirects which confuse some readers. In this example, it was only three, and they would be easily found by reading the [[The Foo]] page itself; there are certainly other cases where it is not so easy and more prolific.


Version: unspecified
Severity: normal

Details

Reference
bz16743

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Lowest.Nov 21 2014, 10:27 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz16743.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

This works for me locally, using a copy of [[Template:Main]] from enwiki.

jerryopennap wrote:

It does not work on enwiki. But you can keep this bugzilla request closed, as I am now persuing a bot to perform this check, and have expanded the scope to include checking for links to disambiguation pages, and redlinks. ~~~~

(In reply to comment #2)

It does not work on enwiki. But you can keep this bugzilla request closed, as
I am now persuing a bot to perform this check, and have expanded the scope to
include checking for links to disambiguation pages, and redlinks. ~~~~

Have you actually *tried* adding new entries, or are you just basing this on missing entries for existing links?

jerryopennap wrote:

I am basing this on missing entries for existing links.