Page MenuHomePhabricator

Archiving breaks links
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

The minute an archive is created, all links are broken, and the user is expected to manually search through Archive 111, 110, 109 etc. until he finds the original link.
E.g., https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons_talk:Geocoding#Template:Object_location_should_not_zap_item_from_map
There must be a better way.
What's worse is such links are not only on Special:Contributions but also on Special:Notifications Wikimedia-wide...
"A quick click on a notification" leads to "an archivist's hour long effort digging through the archives for a broken non-permalink".

Event Timeline

Hi, the concept of "archiving" does not exist in MediaWiki itself. When content or a complete page is moved, then content cannot be accessed anymore. I don't see how to fix this in MediaWiki itself. (For fixing "archiving" page/content move approaches that some websites might have, you'll have to contact those websites, I'm afraid.)

Restricted Application added a subscriber: pywikibot-bugs-list. · View Herald Transcript

It is a common practice on all Wikimedia owned wikis, not any particular one.
It is not a common practice outside of Wikimedia owned wikis.
If phabricator.wikimedia.org is the wrong place to post this, where on *.wikimedia.org is?

Thanks! (but let's hope one day permalinks that survive archiving get invented.)

It's worth noting that enwiki is currently considering making the userscript a gadget - see VPT discussion.