As of now (2025-12-07) https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q18644427 (obsolete Wikidata property) has two subclasses:
- https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q60457486 (Wikidata property for a discontinued website; 151 properties use it as "instance of" - 59 in 2022 -: https://w.wiki/GXwf)
- https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q108951239 (Wikidata property for a former identification scheme; 99 properties use it as "instance of" - 26 in 2022 -: https://w.wiki/GXwR).
Out of 13080 properties, 9868 (query: https://w.wiki/GXx5) have the datatype external-id; 248 properties (query: https://w.wiki/GXxP) external-id (about 1.9% of the external identifiers) are obsolete and their number will obviously grow - in 2022 the properties were 9742, the external IDs 6920, the obsolete external IDs 85 (about 1.2%) -.
I propose:
- to reflect if, in order to mark these external IDs as obsolete, using "instance of" with the two aforementioned values is the best option or if we need a different way to mark obsolescence
- to create a subsection Obsolete identifiers in the present section Identifiers for storing these obsolete external IDs (the external IDs going into this subsection could maybe be managed through https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/MediaWiki:Wikibase-SortedProperties)
- to make the subsection Obsolete identifiers collapsible and to give registered users the possibility to autocollapse it through Preferences > Appearence (or > Gadgets)