Page MenuHomePhabricator

Management of obsolete external-identifier properties on Wikidata
Open, MediumPublic

Description

As of now (2025-12-07) https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q18644427 (obsolete Wikidata property) has two subclasses:

Out of 13080 properties, 9868 (query: https://w.wiki/GXx5) have the datatype external-id; 248 properties (query: https://w.wiki/GXxP) external-id (about 1.9% of the external identifiers) are obsolete and their number will obviously grow - in 2022 the properties were 9742, the external IDs 6920, the obsolete external IDs 85 (about 1.2%) -.

I propose:

  1. to reflect if, in order to mark these external IDs as obsolete, using "instance of" with the two aforementioned values is the best option or if we need a different way to mark obsolescence
  2. to create a subsection Obsolete identifiers in the present section Identifiers for storing these obsolete external IDs (the external IDs going into this subsection could maybe be managed through https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/MediaWiki:Wikibase-SortedProperties)
  3. to make the subsection Obsolete identifiers collapsible and to give registered users the possibility to autocollapse it through Preferences > Appearence (or > Gadgets)

Event Timeline

Alternative version of points 2 and 3:

  1. to automatically mark obsolete external IDs in a way different from other external IDs (e.g. some different color)
  2. to give registered users the possibility to group obsolete external IDs in a subsection Obsolete identifiers of the section Identifiers and to autocollapse it through Preferences > Appearence (or > Gadgets)

I had a similar request independently. In my opinion, we should hide or separate IDs that are becoming obsolete or whose platforms are not currently updated. This could be accomplished with a specific qualifier.

We should also establish a policy for determining which IDs can be removed completely. However, some IDs may have been useful as a source, so we should keep track of their presence in the architecture of our items in an organized manner.

The ID section is also quite cluttered for a lot of older items, so we could also consider hiding obsolete IDs from non-registered users.

We should also establish a policy for determining which IDs can be removed completely. However, some IDs may have been useful as a source, so we should keep track of their presence in the architecture of our items in an organized manner.

Keep in mind that many older ID's are still in Wikidata for legacy reasons: as soon as a database stopped being available, this does not mean that the identifiers are no longer in use at all. They are often used in various places outside the original database and for future reference it would be good to keep the identifiers from older databases available to be able match them with Wikidata items and other identifiers.

The possibility to hide seems fine, but not hiding without the option to unhide.

Epidosis updated the task description. (Show Details)
zdev triaged this task as Medium priority.Sep 14 2026, 6:44 PM