Page MenuHomePhabricator

Import DicoAdo DNS zone in WMCH nameserver
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

  • dicoado.org:

1; Domain: dicoado.org
2; Exported (y-m-d hh:mm:ss): 2022-10-13 15:24:55
3; Actual version
4
5$TTL 3600
6@ IN SOA nsany1.infomaniak.com. hostmaster.infomaniak.ch. (2022101335 10800 3600 605800 3600)
7* 300 IN A 83.166.138.13
8* 300 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
9*.fr 300 IN CNAME dicoado.org.
10 300 IN A 83.166.138.13
11 300 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
12 300 IN MX 5 mta-gw.infomaniak.ch.
13 300 IN NS nsany1.infomaniak.com.
14 300 IN NS nsany2.infomaniak.com.
15 300 IN TXT "google-site-verification=JNcDAsNvoSvz6R8uKGfHgEAN4M3qaurbO-CxudRhobo"
16 300 IN TXT "v=spf1 include:spf.infomaniak.ch ?all"
17autoconfig 300 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
18autodiscover 300 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
19fr 300 IN CNAME dicoado.org.
20matomo 300 IN A 89.207.237.60
21wmch 300 IN A 89.207.237.145
22wmch.fr 300 IN A 89.207.237.145
23_domainkey 3600 IN NS nsany1.infomaniak.com.
24_domainkey 3600 IN NS nsany2.infomaniak.com.

  • dicoado.ch (alias):

1; Domain: dicoado.ch
2; Exported (y-m-d hh:mm:ss): 2022-10-13 15:26:41
3; Actual version
4
5$TTL 3600
6@ IN SOA ns11.infomaniak.ch. hostmaster.infomaniak.ch. (2022080936 10800 3600 605800 3600)
7* 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
8* 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
9 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
10 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
11 3600 IN MX 5 mta-gw.infomaniak.ch.
12 3600 IN NS ns11.infomaniak.ch.
13 3600 IN NS ns12.infomaniak.ch.
14 3600 IN TXT "v=spf1 include:spf.infomaniak.ch ?all"
1547cf3f8863a12cec28f1a3af6721ec1a 3600 IN CNAME verify.bing.com.
16autoconfig 3600 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
17autodiscover 3600 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
18www 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
19www 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
20_domainkey 3600 IN NS ns11.infomaniak.ch.
21_domainkey 3600 IN NS ns12.infomaniak.ch.

  • dicoado.com (alias):

1; Domain: dicoado.com
2; Exported (y-m-d hh:mm:ss): 2022-10-13 15:27:19
3; Actual version
4
5$TTL 3600
6@ IN SOA ns11.infomaniak.ch. hostmaster.infomaniak.ch. (2022080909 10800 3600 605800 3600)
7* 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
8* 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
9 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
10 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
11 3600 IN MX 5 mta-gw.infomaniak.ch.
12 3600 IN NS ns11.infomaniak.ch.
13 3600 IN NS ns12.infomaniak.ch.
14 3600 IN TXT "v=spf1 include:spf.infomaniak.ch ?all"
15autoconfig 3600 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
16autodiscover 3600 IN CNAME infomaniak.com.
17www 3600 IN A 83.166.138.13
18www 3600 IN AAAA 2001:1600:4:13:1a66:daff:fe5c:a57b
19_domainkey 3600 IN NS ns11.infomaniak.ch.
20_domainkey 3600 IN NS ns12.infomaniak.ch.

Event Timeline

I tried some ways but I'm not allowed from our DNS panel to import the configuration WITHOUT transferring the ownership to Wikimedia CH. We have a ticket opened to fix this problem, since we don't want downtimes.

(The upstream ticket in WMCH is still opened. We need to wait.)

Please note that the screenshoot is outdated :-)
Technically, this isn't even needed. The DNS zone can still be hosted in infomaniak.

This is declined :) not because WMCH does not want it; but for the exact contrary reason:

This is declined because WMCH asked to import everything in WMCH (to manage DNS with WMCH's name servers) but I see more downsides than benefits in doing this. The most prominent benefit would be: WMCH being more independent in updating DNS records (but without many proofs, since, at the moment, I'm authorized to manage the DNS area of dicoado.org, and, Lorangeo is very fast in updating their DNS area as well as far as I can see).

Downside of importing everything in WMCH: we really have no collaboration tools for the DNS area, so, community owners would be excluded from this management (as far as I can see).

Since I know that both Vivian and Lorangeo has sufficient IT expertise to manage their DNS zones, therefore I'm inclined to preserve this balanced situation, at least at the moment, since we have more downsides than benefits.