This task is about making it so comments posted with the Reply Tool do not appear //within// templates/tables published by way of Barnstars/Wikilove.
This task contains two cases:
- **Case 1**
- **Case 2**
**Case 1** was resolved, we think, in June 2020.
**Case 2** is not yet resolved.
---
=== Cases
**Case 1** (June, 2020)
The "right" location for a reply has traditionally been determined through human judgment. See https://hu.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Szerkesztővita:Pasztilla&curid=258186&diff=22453105&oldid=22452319 on @Pasztilla's talk page:
{F31755731}
The reply ended up inside the box (table), but it belongs outside. However, some editors use tables, div elements, etc., to create a decorative border or background color around the entire page, and in that case, comments belong inside the box. What should we do?
**Case 2** (November, 2020)
Comment posted with the Reply Tool appears //within// Barnstar at fa.wiki. //See: https://w.wiki/mjB .//
---
=== Behavior
1. Navigate to a discussion page where someone has left a Barnstar. //E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:PPelberg_(WMF)/sandbox?dtenable=1#Testing_phab:_T250126 //
2. Click the `[ reply ]` link that is appended to the barnstar. In this case, it's the `The Tireless Contributor Barnstar`.
3. Notice the Reply Tool opens
4. Write a comment
5. Publish the comment you drafted in "Step 4"
6. Notice the comment you published in "Step 5" appears //beneath// the Barnstar you replied to in "Step 1" [i]
---
|i.
|---
|{F33916292}