When selecting yes/no when classifying some edits in Wikilabels (which uses OOUI) I couldn't see the system showing clearly whether I had changed a No to a Yes. I was learning to use Wikipedia:Labels with Gediz at Wikimania 2015 on an old Windows laptop running the Monobook skin on en.wp.
Description
Description
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
I tried that in monobook. I understand it's hard to see a button is selected but that's monobook and it's an upstream issue which my guess is it won't be solved. Theses CSS designs are out of our hand:
Comment Actions
@Ladsgroup What is exactly meant by “selecting” here? Keyboard focus, actively pushing the button, …?
Comment Actions
actively pushing the button (:active). I haven't checked on :focus but I'm guessing it's much worse.
Comment Actions
@Ladsgroup Thanks! I still don't understand what the issue is exactly about, as the buttons do have a strong visual :activestate by inverting the gradient.
Comment Actions
hmm, the problem is that they are not showing they got selected. It's a little bit difficult to explain. Let me grab an example:
They are clearly different but it's hard to tell which one is the active one (especially from far) and that's why it's problematic in wikilabels because we choose an option between different cases then it's hard to come back and say which one you chose. (Maybe we should've gone with RadioButton but that's another topic)
Comment Actions
@Ladsgroup I see. Yes, that seems to be more a false choice of library widget than a flaw in the library itself. Those are not meant to be used in such context.
Comment Actions
Is this still relevant now that Wikilabels lives at https://labels.wmflabs.org ? It imports enwiki's vector CSS since 2016