Page MenuHomePhabricator

Request a new Property WikiTreeCategory - P7607
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Task: Request a new Property WikiTreeCategory see Proposal and please vote

Status created: Property 7607
Feedback from T236340: POC WikiTree categories: Connect Swedish Church Parishes in Wikidata to categories in a wiki at a community of genealogists called WikiTree from people at WikiTree working with data quality WikiTree <-> Wikidata see Space:Data_Doctors_Report

Below example how Wikidata is used in WikiTree for quality checks, see also video explaining Wikidata mismatch

Example of a help page for Wikidata mismatch in WikiTree Space:DBE_541

Example of Video created to explain Wikidata for WikiTree people

  1. WikiTree has today > 70 000 people connected Property 2949
    1. they use the Wikidata constraint violations reports to check the data for
      1. Duplicates
      2. Unique value
    2. Other checks done
      1. 541 Wikidata - Clue for Father
      2. 542 WikiData - Possible Father on WikiData
      3. 543 Wikidata - Clue for Mother
      4. 544 WikiData - Possible Mother on WikiData
      5. 546 Wikidata - Possible spouse
      6. 551 Wikidata - Missing gender
      7. 552 Wikidata - Different gender
      8. 553 Wikidata - Empty birth date
      9. 554 Wikidata - Imprecise birth date
      10. 555 Wikidata - Different birth date
      11. 556 Wikidata - Empty death date
      12. 557 Wikidata - Imprecise death date
      13. 558 Wikidata - Different death date
      14. 559 Wikidata - Missing birth location
      15. 561 Wikidata - Missing death location
      16. 563 Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father
      17. 564 Wikidata - Possible father
      18. 565 Wikidata - Possible duplicate by mother
      19. 566 Wikidata - Possible mother
      20. 567 WikiData Double entry - explained in video

By mixing WikiTree people and WikiTree categories in one Wikidata property will makes this less useful as Categories for e.g. a Swedish Parish in WikiTree could be same as two objects in Wikidata as we have decided to model the objects in a different way in Wikidata. This can be handled with exceptions (see Property 778) but splitting the property in one for human and one for Categories/Spaces feels a cleaner solution

Event Timeline

Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)
Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)
Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)
Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)
Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)
Salgo60 renamed this task from Request a new Property WikiTreeCategory to Request a new Property WikiTreeCategory - P7607.Nov 25 2019, 8:09 AM
Salgo60 closed this task as Resolved.
Salgo60 updated the task description. (Show Details)


Aklapper moved this task from Backlog to Done on the User-Salgo60 board.