Page MenuHomePhabricator

No log entry for deleted page
Open, LowPublic


Author: yoenit

The page "Organizations in A Song of Ice and Fire" on enwiki was deleted after an AFD some 7 months ago. (see "Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organizations in A Song of Ice and Fire") However, no log entry of this deletion appears to exist. I checked with the deleting admin and an oversighter, who confirmed that the page was indeed deleted, the deleted revision are still visible and oversight was not used.

Version: unspecified
Severity: normal



Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Low.Nov 21 2014, 11:28 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz29125.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

Looks like this happened in September/October 2010:

Probably a failure to save the log entry at the time; race condition bugs and such probably remain but can't be tracked down specifically related to this page deletion instance.

wikipedia.phantomsteve wrote:

It did happen in October. I deleted the page, redirects to it and the page's talk page, all of which are showing in the deletion log with the exception of this one page:

(see for my deletions from 3 October)

The following were all deleted:

  • Talk:Organizations in A Song of Ice and Fire
  • The Unsullied
  • Unsullied
  • The Second Sons
  • Night’s Watch
  • The Brave Companions
  • Brotherhood Without Banners
  • Maesters of the Citadel
  • Vargo Hoat
  • Wildlings
  • Faceless Men
  • Pycelle
  • Luwin
  • Wildling
  • The bearded priests of Norvos
  • Maester Luwin
  • Yoren
  • Maesters
  • The Faith Militant
  • Greenseers
  • Grand Maester Pycelle
  • The Golden Company
  • The Sorrowful Men
  • The Citadel (A Song of Ice and Fire)
  • Others(ASOIAF)
  • Night´s Watch

They were all deleted within a minute or so of each other, and so was the main page.

I'd guess it's a blip, but if someone could give a definitive answer, that'd be good!

Same error observed. Steps:

  1. Went to Wikipedia deletion log
  2. Searched for provided Article Name
  3. Result: "No items matching in log"

Is this an issue that continues to appear?