Page MenuHomePhabricator

Allow circumventing the 'too much unchanged text' safety when publishing in personal sandbox
Closed, DuplicatePublic

Description

In the page translation feature, I like to 'show my work' in the page history. This means that I would publish a version as soon as possible, before making all the edits. The advantage is that I have access to many more advanced tools that the translation interface does not have, while still benefiting from all the initial boost that the page translation tool can give, including connecting links to the right pages and sorting out the references and templates.

Currently, when I try to do this, I keep getting errors because I have too much 'unchanged' text (not sure if this is the exact phrase in English, as I get the message in Dutch). Reproduce:
On nlwiki go to your edits, translations, enter an article in enwiki that doesn't exist in nlwiki and select translate. Click on all the sections to trigger initial translation. Select 'sandbox' as destination.

This is a good safety feature to keep the community off the developers' back in complaints that the tool is overused by newcomers, but I wonder if there's not a better way to give experienced editors a way to integrate this tool more efficiently in their workflows (e.g. the translate tool is harder to create some links, integrate different templates, move text between sections or switch between source and visual).

Event Timeline

Thanks for the feedback, @Effeietsanders.

Not applying the current limits to user namespace is something we have in our plans (T215403).
This is part of a set of initiatives aimed at improving the current limit system (T251887).
Finding a balanced system that blocks low quality translations while allowing legitimate ones is not a simple task, and we want to adjust the current set of limits before adjusting how they are exposed.