Page MenuHomePhabricator

truncated copyright notice
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Author: hardy

Description:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Ruled_hyperboloid.jpg

I uploaded this picture, with copyright information saying
that the head of the math department at the University of
Arizona had granted a GNU Free Documentation License for
all pictures found at a specified website, and I gave the
URL for that site. I don't think I was warned before I
clicked on "save", that the information I entered would get
truncated, so that it says:

"GNU Free Documentation License granted by Prof. William
McCallum, head of the department, for all picture"

where it should have said:

"GNU Free Documentation License granted by Prof. William
McCallum, head of the department, for all pictures
at http://math.arizona.edu/~models"

And I don't see anything on the image page that enables me
to edit the notice further.


Version: unspecified
Severity: normal

Details

Reference
bz5473

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Unbreak Now!.Nov 21 2014, 9:09 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz5473.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

hardy wrote:

"Edit this page" DID NOT WORK the first time I tried it.

NOW I click on that, and I find all of the copyright
information, but what appears when I view the page itself
is the truncated version.

I'm going to edit to fit it into the space allowed.

Still, there should be a warning that it will get truncated.
This information is important.

hardy wrote:

It still doesn't work!! I edited the copyright information to
make it short enough to fit. But when I view the image page,
and reload, I still see the original truncated notice.

Looks fine to me.

There shouldn't be a warning about truncation because truncation shouldn't happen.

hardy wrote:

I now see that the correct information is under "summary",
but the original truncated notice is under "file history".
People reading the truncated version may be led to think
a license has been granted for all pictures on the department's
web pages, rather than those under a specified URL.

Is there any way to edit the TRUNCATED copyright information
in the "file history" section?

No, that's an upload comment. You cannot edit it ever, it's an event-specific one-time
comment, like all edit comments.

I'm duping this to 2537; preview and separation of the existing *comment* field from a
potential full description field.

  • This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 2537 ***

hardy wrote:

... and the danger of misunderstanding persists.

Usually edit comments are not made so conspicuous,
right there on the page that was edited. What if
the edit comments upon creation of a new Wikipedia
article were always displayed conspicuously on the
page, and could never be altered?

Restricted Application added subscribers: Steinsplitter, Matanya. · View Herald Transcript