Currently the number shown is inclusive of abandoned proposals.
Description
Description
Revisions and Commits
Revisions and Commits
| Restricted Differential Revision |
Related Objects
Related Objects
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
I want to work on this issue. Could you please help me reproduce this? I checked the aggregated scores page which doesn't show abandoned proposals.
Comment Actions
Ah, that's not the right page. Go to Admin > Manage Campaigns > Report by Reviewer. (Make sure you have some reviewed proposals first)
So according to this ticket, the "Total proposals received" there includes abandoned proposals. Can you verify if that's still the case?
Comment Actions
Ah, that's not the right page. Go to Admin > Manage Campaigns > Report by Reviewer. (Make sure you have some reviewed proposals first)
Thanks for the steps.
Can you verify if that's still the case?
Yes. "Total proposals received" and "Proposals reviewed" both include abandoned proposals.
This is due to the fact that the queries do not have conditions for the status of proposals.
If a proposal is reviewed and then abandoned, it still shows up in "Link to proposals reviewed". I don't think this is desired behavior. Should we fix that as well?
Comment Actions
Correct. We should fix this.
If a proposal is reviewed and then abandoned, it still shows up in "Link to proposals reviewed". I don't think this is desired behavior. Should we fix that as well?
I'm unsure if the right thing to do would be to completely remove the proposal from the list or to show some kind of indication that the proposal has been abandoned.
A common use case for abandoning proposals is when participants submit multiple proposals. Reviewers might start reviewing proposals but when one later gets abandoned, they might want to copy over that data to the other proposal which is yet unreviewed but has same content. This is not a very common use case but it might exist. Create a ticket for this and we'll discuss it afterwards. Not a part of this ticket.