Page MenuHomePhabricator

Allow viewing of own contribs on Special:DeletedContributions
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

Administrators can use Special:DeletedContributions to search for user contributions that have been deleted before. However, most users gain many deleted contribs over time, maybe by patrolling new pages, or by doing simple mistakes. Reviewing these revisions would make many things easier, especially for newbies:

  • After a sysop deleted your work, you can review what you did wrong to understand his concerns. You can still see a record of your work, it isn't gone.
  • You can comprehend your own wiki-history even years later and do some statistics.
  • Really problematic things are hidden by oversight anyway.

However, this also introduces some problems:

  • You can just repost deleted content if you can read it.
  • The associated copyright information is missing.
  • Some content is deleted because of prrivacy issues or because they are offending. They shouldn't resurface.
  • Deleted revisions shouldn't be a private information store for users.

That's why I propose introducing two new permissions: mydeletedhistory and mydeletedtext, analogous to the existing permissions, but just for own revisions. While I intend the latter for third-party wikis, I thing the first one can actually be useful on WMF-wikis as well, as it mitigates the problems mentioned before almost entirely while preserving major parts of the benefits.

In UI, I propose

  • Showing the "Deleted contributions" links for users with mydeletedhistory on Special:Contributions/me
  • Forwarding from "Special:DeletedContributions" to "Special:Contributions/me" if you have mydeletedhistory, but no deletedhistory
  • Greying out "IP address or username:" field at the special page (containing the own user name). If the user would query the information about another user, he would get a permission error.

API changes might be required as well.

Event Timeline

This has been requested on German Community Wishlist 2015, but didn't make it into the Top 20. Nevertheless, WMDE intended to work on this at some point, as it's relatively easy to implement.

Aklapper renamed this task from Allow viewing of own contribs on Special:DeletedContibutions to Allow viewing of own contribs on Special:DeletedContributions.Oct 31 2018, 1:40 PM

This proposal seems to be legally infeasible.

DannyS712 added a subscriber: DannyS712.

This proposal seems to be legally infeasible.

WMF-Legal can you confirm if this is the case?

Considering the European GDPR, we might even be legally mandated to provide this information to users, as users have the right to access any information a given website is storing about him.

WMF-Legal can you confirm if this is the case?

Please see https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/project/profile/28/ : "Phabricator is not the place to expect or receive feedback."