In T203043 we gathered some feedback mostly from Experienced editors from English Wikipedia. In this task we will elicit feedback from more experienced editors, recruited from at least 3 of the following languages: Arabic, French, Spanish, Japanese, or Russian.
In this round in order to focus the feedback on the recommendations themselves, rather than the interface, we won't use the secrec testing tool. Instead, we'll provide lists of recommendations for particular articles, and ask people for two basic kinds of feedback:
- (overall practical quality) how useful are these recommendations? (esp. whether they conform with local wiki policies or MoS)
- (design requirements for API) if these recommendations were presented in the context of a tool/bot/gadget, how would you (as an end user, or gadget developer) want to be able to provide feedback on the recommendations?