Page MenuHomePhabricator

Exploratory analysis of readers’ knowledge networks (Q4)
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Following the analysis on readers’ curiosity (Lydon-Staley et al.), we want to characterize the knowledge networks of Wikipedia’s readers.

  • Generate knowledge networks using features from navigation, hyperlinks, and textual similarity of articles.
  • Implement metrics to characterize knowledge networks such as clustering
  • Exploratory analysis of the variation of knowledge networks

Event Timeline

Update week 2022-04-04:

Update week 2022-04-11:

  • Started to implement network features for different networks:
  • Clustering, Characteristic Path Length, Small-world propensity, and core-periphery structure (code). This requires some iterations to adapt to the specific use-case (e.g. weighted networks)
  • Extract meso-scale structure from fitting blockmodels with graph-tool. This allows us to quantify modularity and compression of the network (code)

Update week 2022-04-18:

  • continuing to implement different network-metrics, including the comparison with random null models.

Update week 2022-04-25:

Update week 2022-05-02:

Update week 2022-05-09:

  • looking at descriptive statistics of network metrics and comparing with statistics from KNOT-data

Update week 2022-05-16:

Update week 2022-05-30:

  • given the similarity in the knowledge networks of Wikipedia readers and KNOT-study, we have been trying to reproduce the findings that there are 2 main types of readers characterized by hunter- and busybody-style of curiosity.

Update week 2022-06-06:

  • continuing analysis of knowledge networks of readers. main principal component seems to be associated with hunter and busybody types described in Lydon-Staley etal. Performing robustness checks of the results by calculating additional network metrics and comparing with Random Walk models.

Update week 2022-06-13:

  • added dataset of knowledge networks from targeted navigation (wikispeedia-data) for comparison. The corresponding networks are substantially different than navigation of Wikipedia readers (specifically in terms of shorter characteristic path lengths)
  • compiled different results from the first exploratory analysis. We will prepare a summary and started to discuss next steps for the analysis.

Update week 2022-06-20:

  • debugging the calculation of some metrics for the knowledge networks
  • summarizing results and discussing next steps

Update week 2022-06-27:

  • writing up results of first round of exploratory analysis for meta

Update week 2022-07-18:

  • finishing write-up for meta about the first round of exploratory analysis (planning to put on meta next week)
  • sketched first draft for the structure of the paper

Update week 2022-07-25: