Page MenuHomePhabricator

"ALT" text should be lower in fallback chain for caption generation
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_inauguration_of_Barack_Obama#mediaviewer/File:US_President_Barack_Obama_taking_his_Oath_of_Office_-_2009Jan20.jpg

is displayed with the caption "Barack Obama holds his right hand in the air as he and Michelle Obama both smile towards a balding man whose back is to the camera while a large crowd watches." It seems to me like the ALT text should be in the fallback chain after the file description, not before, as it is often written specifically for users with screen readers.

Event Timeline

Eloquence raised the priority of this task from to Needs Triage.
Eloquence updated the task description. (Show Details)
Eloquence added projects: MediaViewer, Multimedia.
Eloquence changed Security from none to None.
Eloquence added a subscriber: Eloquence.

The ALT text is not used for fallback; the link title is. The wikitext format is [[File:filename.ext|frameless|title|alt=alt text]]. See example where the two are different.

The infobox template apparently uses the alt text as the title, instead of the caption; IMO that doesn't make much sense.

As for actually using the alt text (which we currently don't), see T75923 and T66519.

Tgr claimed this task.

Left some messages about it on-wiki:

Closing this ticket as I don't see anything that could be done on the software side about this.

Makes sense, thanks for following up on-wiki!