Page MenuHomePhabricator

Maintenance templates above deletion tags
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

[[WP:ORDER]] indicates that deletion tags should go above maintenance tags. However, AWB functionality does not always follow this guide:

  • AWB adds {{Underlinked}} above {{Prod blp/dated}} (e.g. [[Chaudry Rehman Kang]])
  • AWB does not move {{Orphan}} below {{Prod blp/dated}} (e.g. [[Svitlana Dekar]])
  • AWB does not move {{Autobiography}} below {{Prod blp/dated}} (e.g. [[William Flageollet]])
  • AWB does not move {{Multiple issues}} below {{Prod blp/dated}} (e.g. [[Fu, Jin]])
  • AWB does not move {{Multiple issues}} below {{Article for deletion/dated}} (e.g. [[Rev. Fr. Dr. Jesu Pudumai Doss]])

Event Timeline

GoingBatty raised the priority of this task from to Medium.
GoingBatty updated the task description. (Show Details)
GoingBatty added a project: AutoWikiBrowser.
GoingBatty renamed this task from Adds {{Underlinked}} above {{Prod blp/dated}} to Maintenance templates above {{Prod blp/dated}}.Sep 6 2015, 7:52 PM
GoingBatty updated the task description. (Show Details)
GoingBatty set Security to None.
GoingBatty updated the task description. (Show Details)
GoingBatty renamed this task from Maintenance templates above {{Prod blp/dated}} to Maintenance templates above deletion tags.Sep 6 2015, 8:01 PM
GoingBatty updated the task description. (Show Details)
Rjwilmsi claimed this task.
Rjwilmsi subscribed.

rev 11436 Add "Prod blp/dated", "Proposed deletion/dated", "Transwiki/dated" to deletion templates list

Could you please reopen this task? AWB SVN 11376 still doesn't move the maintenance tags below the deletion tags.
Thanks!

@GoingBatty, changes are in rev 11436, yet you're testing with 11376?

Sorry about that - compiled SVN 11437 but then somehow ran the old version. Two comments after testing with SVN 11437:

  • Could the maintenance templates be moved below the {{Prod blp/dated}} template AND its associated comment? (e.g. first four articles listed above)
  • SVN 11437 is still not moving {{Multiple issues}} below {{Article for deletion/dated}} (e.g. [[Rev. Fr. Dr. Jesu Pudumai Doss]])

Thanks!

OK, {{article for deletion}} is a new can of worms. @GoingBatty Which of the templates at [[Category:Articles for deletion templates]] in addition to {{Article for deletion/dated}} and {{Article for deletion}} should be considered as deletion tags as well?

rev 11438, Add "Article for deletion/dated", "Article for deletion" to DeletionProtectionTags

rev 11439 Handle blp prod comment when moving the blp prod/dated template

Using SVN 11439, I confirmed that the blp prod comment is properly handled and that {{Article for deletion/dated}} is now moved above {{Multiple issues}}. Could you also please handle the {{Article for deletion/dated}} comments?

Thanks!

rev 11440, keep comments with deletion template when moving deletion template

@Rjwilmsi - Sorry, SVN 11440 still doesn't keep the comments with {{Article for deletion/dated}} in [[Rev. Fr. Dr. Jesu Pudumai Doss]]

rev 11444, handle multiple comments before and after deletion tag

Confirmed with SVN 11444 - thanks!