As shown in
Description
Description
Details
Details
| Subject | Repo | Branch | Lines +/- | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suggestions: Visually group the non-personal suggestions | mediawiki/extensions/ContentTranslation | master | +46 -26 |
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
Change 250860 had a related patch set uploaded (by Santhosh):
Suggestions: Visually group the non-personal suggestions
Comment Actions
Change 250860 merged by jenkins-bot:
Suggestions: Visually group the non-personal suggestions
Comment Actions
Just to clarify, in the mockup you can see:
- "For later" list. This includes items the user explicitly added to the list. we can consider this a personal collection.
- Suggestions list which includes individual suggestions (e.g., "Golden Toad") and some suggested list ("Wiki loves science"). None of those is created by the user. Thus, they are not personal collections. Users may be able to add these suggested items to their personal collection ("for later" or other lists) but we are not supporting this yet.
I guess the ticket is referred to suggested lists (or campaigns), not personal collections.
Comment Actions
One minor difference observed from the original design - the list items begin immediately after 'More suggestion' label, whereas in the design there are a couple of other suggestions below the label followed by list items and then another set after the 'View all'. Any opinion @Pginer-WMF ? Thanks.
Comment Actions
Any opinion @Pginer-WMF ?
Thanks @Arrbee for pointing at this.
The main design intent is to have a single section of suggestions where users can find both individual articles and also other suggestions grouped together (into a campaign).
The specific order in which those suggestions appear is not something to worry much about for now (since users can discard and suggestions have always certain degree of randomness). There are some principles to make the list of suggestions easier to process and understand; we could try to encourage such as avoiding multiple lists being shown at the same time or starting with individual items. But that should not be a blocker for this ticket.
If we observe that showing campaigns on top is problematic (e.g., a user thinks that all suggestions are about "Villages in the Kutch district" and ignores the rest of the list missing the opportunity to translate the Yellowstone article), then we should do some adjustments in that regard. But for now, those are just some hypothesis to pay attention to as users make use of suggestions.