Page MenuHomePhabricator

Replace tracking bug T125033 by new project tag "Chinese-Sites"
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Name: Chinese-Sites
Description: track Chinese Wikimedia projects
Type of project: tag

Event Timeline

Shizhao raised the priority of this task from to Needs Triage.
Shizhao updated the task description. (Show Details)
Shizhao added a project: Project-Admins.
Shizhao added a subscriber: Shizhao.

Would this include all language variants like zh-hans, zh-hant, etc. / zh_TW, zh_HK, zh_CN, etc.?
And is there interest from several Chinese community members? :)

Would this include all language variants like zh-hans, zh-hant, etc. / zh_TW, zh_HK, zh_CN, etc.?
And is there interest from several Chinese community members? :)

yes

And is there interest from several Chinese community members? :)

yes

I must say [citation needed]

OTOH, the "Chinese-Sites" is confusing to me, is this:

  • only zhwiki, zhwiktionary, zhwikibooks, zhwikinews, zhwikiquote, zhwikisource, zhwikivoyage <del>and zhwikiversity</del>?
  • the Wikimedia sites that Chinese people use (wikis above, plus cdowiki, hakwiki, zh-min-nanwiki, zh-yuewiki, etc.)
  • the Wikimedia sites that just include Chinese contents? (can have /zh, /zh-hans, /zh-hant translation pages on Commons/Meta-Wiki/Wikidata/Incubator?)
  • Very just the Chinese MediaWiki websites? (can include non-WMF Chinese sites e.g. http://wiki.52poke.com ?)

And is there interest from several Chinese community members? :)

yes

I must say [citation needed]

OTOH, the "Chinese-Sites" is confusing to me, is this:

  • only zhwiki, zhwiktionary, zhwikibooks, zhwikinews, zhwikiquote, zhwikisource, zhwikivoyage <del>and zhwikiversity</del>?
  • the Wikimedia sites that Chinese people use (wikis above, plus cdowiki, hakwiki, zh-min-nanwiki, zh-yuewiki, etc.)
  • the Wikimedia sites that just include Chinese contents? (can have /zh, /zh-hans, /zh-hant translation pages on Commons/Meta-Wiki/Wikidata/Incubator?)
  • Very just the Chinese MediaWiki websites? (can include non-WMF Chinese sites e.g. http://wiki.52poke.com ?)

only zhwiki, zhwiktionary, zhwikibooks, zhwikinews, zhwikiquote, zhwikisource, zhwikivoyage, zzhwiki include all language variants like zh-hans, zh-hant, etc. / zh_TW, zh_HK, zh_CN, etc.

Luke081515 renamed this task from Create "Chinese-Sites" project to track Chinese Wikimedia projects to Replace tracking bug T125033 by new project tag "Chinese-Sites".Feb 12 2016, 10:09 PM
Luke081515 set Security to None.

There is a lot of controversy around this tag now: i keep seeing Liuxinyu970226 and Shizhao "spam" reports with discussions on this or that edit (e.g. T151269#2904524).

Can you two please find a shared agreement on the usage of this tag etc., and at any rate resolve your disagreements in a central page such as your mediawiki.org user talks? Thanks.

There is a lot of controversy around this tag now: i keep seeing Liuxinyu970226 and Shizhao "spam" reports with discussions on this or that edit (e.g. T151269#2904524).

Can you two please find a shared agreement on the usage of this tag etc., and at any rate resolve your disagreements in a central page such as your mediawiki.org user talks? Thanks.

Where's my spam reports?

IN removed a subscriber: IN.