Page MenuHomePhabricator

Review and fix Wikipedia logos on mobile site
Closed, DuplicatePublic

Description

@Esanders points out there are are 86 different logos for over 127 wikis that are not localised to English.

Let's go through the table and where a logo exists update it for the other projects.
Set the default for Wikipedia to 'text'.
If @Nirzar has provided a new logo that should be updated as part of this task

Localised logoprojectcorrect logo?
BiquipédiamwlN
GüiquipeyaextN
HuiquipedianahN
UicipeidgdN
VichipediefurN
VicipaedialaN
VicipéidgaN
VikipedejaltgN
VikipeditrN
VikipediivepN
VikipedijaltN
VikipedioeoN
Vikipediyaaz, crh, gag, uzN
VikipedyaladN
VikipeediaetN
VikipetãgnN
VikipidiyarmyN
VikipēdijalvN
ViquipèdiacaY
VouiquipèdiafrpN
VükipedvoN
WicipediacyY
Wikipediecs, nds-nlN
WikipediioloN
Wikipedijadsb, hr, hsb, mt, slN
WikipedioioN
WikipediýatkN
WikipedyfyN
WikipedyahtN
WikipetciaatjN
Wikipidiabjn, jamN
WikipèdiaocN
Wikipédiafr, hu, pt, skY/N (French)
WikipǣdiaangN
WîkîpediyakuN
Βικιπαίδειαel, pntN
АвикипедиаabN
БикипиэдьийэsahN
Википедиce, cv, mrj, osN
Википедиаmn, tgN
ВикипедиеadyN
ВикипедиесьmdfN
ВикипедийmhrN
Википедияba, koi, krc, lbe, lez, ru, tyv, udmY/N (ru is covered)
ВикипедиясьmyvN
Википедијаmk, srY
ВикипєдїꙗcuN
Вікіпедыяbe, rue, ukN
Вікіпэдыяbe-taraskN
УикипедиэkbdN
Уикипедияbg, kkN
ՎիքիպեդիաhyN
ויקיפדיהheY
װיקיפּעדיעyiN
ويكيبيدياar, arzY/N (ar is covered)
ويکيپېډياpsN
وکیپیڈیاpnbN
ویکیپیدیاckbN
ویکیپیڈیاurN
ویکی‌پدیاazb, fa, mznN
ڤیکیپئدیاlrcN
ܘܝܩܝܦܕܝܐarcN
ވިކިޕީޑިއާdvN
विकिपिडियाdty, maiN
विकिपीडियाbh, gom, hi, mr, ne, saY/N (hi is covered)
অসমীয়া ৱিকিপিডিয়াasN
উইকিপিডিয়াbn, bpyY/ N (bn is covered)
ਵਿਕੀਪੀਡੀਆpaN
વિકિપીડિયાguN
ଉଇକିପିଡ଼ିଆorN
விக்கிப்பீடியாtaN
వికీపీడియాteN
ವಿಕಿಪೀಡಿಯkn, tcyN
വിക്കിപീഡിയmlN
විකිපීඩියා, නිදහස් විශ්වකෝෂයsiN
วิกิพีเดียthN
ວິກິພີເດຍloN
ဝီကီပီးဒီးယားmyN
ვიკიპედიაka, xmfN
ውክፔዲያamN
ᐅᐃᑭᐱᑎᐊiuN
វិគីភីឌាkmN
維基大典zh-classicalN
維基百科ganN
维基百科wuuN
위키백과koN

Event Timeline

Jdlrobson renamed this task from Review English Wikipedia logos to Review Wikipedia logos on mobile site.Jul 20 2017, 3:55 PM
Jdlrobson renamed this task from Review Wikipedia logos on mobile site to Review and fix Wikipedia logos on mobile site.
Jdlrobson added a project: Web-Team-Backlog.

As this is quite a long list, wouldn't it be better to switch to a text logo by default (when sitename !== 'Wikipedia'), and then add SVG versions incrementally?

If only this

when sitename !== 'Wikipedia'

is technically possible. that was intended design.

if anyone can achieve that.. let's do it. I want to keep the status quo of "more wikis with correct logo than incorrect one"

Here's early analysis of wordmarks and projects
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JXMMtlSrqbNb6YPKreaQ8zgRqKhaUruJwP5iXYSWG80/edit#gid=1464088164

We have more than 250 wikis with ~170 wikis have the correct "Wikipedia" wordmark. I would want to avoid showing text string instead of wordmark for 170+ wikis.

Jdlrobson triaged this task as Medium priority.Jul 20 2017, 10:13 PM

As @Nirzar says we shouldn't set false as the default as this helps more wikis than it breaks, however if someone has the time to set false for all the wikis we don't have logos for (and enable the ones we do) in that table that would be helpful. It's time consuming and we have lots of other ongoing activities so this is not of the highest priority for us just yet so we've been relying on where we can get the help (several wikis have already been proactive and asked or made their own logos).

this helps more wikis than it breaks

On a quantitative basis, yes. But qualitatively the improvement is purely cosmetic (plain text -> SVG), whereas the downside for non-Latin wikis in particular is that have a logo in a script the users might not be able to read at all.

What is the config setting to use plain text?

@Esanders I don't want to have a fallback of plain text which has such small shelf life.

I have prioritized the work of creating wordmarks for all wikis here - https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T142426
Pending: updating task description with status and tracking

designers will be splitting the work and doing this over next couple of weeks.

Furthermore, is qualitative better here than quantitative is reading web product manager's decision cc @ovasileva
Let's follow reading web process here

Furthermore, is qualitative better here than quantitative is reading web product manager's decision cc @ovasileva

Absolutely! Just sharing my opinion. Having localised SVGs is the ideal solution.