Page MenuHomePhabricator

Wikipedia main portal shown in English instead of Arabic language on an Arabic system
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Assigned To
None
Authored By
alaa
Aug 29 2017, 12:52 PM
Referenced Files
F9230371: changing_chrome_lang_settings-arabic.png
Aug 30 2017, 8:50 PM
F9230373: wikipedia-org_in_arabic.jpg
Aug 30 2017, 8:50 PM
F9204354: wikipedia-portal-ar.mp4.mp4
Aug 29 2017, 1:24 PM
Tokens
"Cookie" token, awarded by debt.

Description

Hello, some users in arwiki asked us about the language of Wikipedia main portal
For example, it's appear to me in Arabic language but appear to other users in arwiki in English!

So How we can change the language of this portal? We try to change the language of the browser or to add (uselang=ar) but it didn't work!

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript

@alanajjar www.wikipedia.org should change languages when you change the language of the browser. This functionality should work in all modern browsers. Below is a video of how I change the browser language in firefox to Arabic and the portal changes. If you can provide any more details about what browsers this doesn't work in (or share the video below to the users having this issue) that would be great. Thanks.

Thanks @Jdrewniak

I posted what you said in arwiki village pump. If f there's any new details from ar-users I'll open it again.

@Jdrewniak as mentioned here one of arwiki user try to change the language of the browser but the language still in English. He uploaded a picture. He is using Chrome browser.

Note that he is the first one who asked about these thing in arwiki.

Hi @alanajjar - I'm not able to reproduce what is going on with the other user on arwiki. Here are my screen shots of changing the language in Chrome and then visiting the wikipedia.org portal page. I've posted a link to this edit on the arwiki page.

changing_chrome_lang_settings-arabic.png (361×726 px, 27 KB)

wikipedia-org_in_arabic.jpg (1×965 px, 369 KB)

@debt The error was corrected in Chrome on the computer, but what about Chrome on the phone? I use Android in Arabic (Phone item:https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q15978789), but the Arabic translation does not appear, what's the solution?Thank you

Aklapper renamed this task from Wikipedia main portal to Wikipedia main portal shown in English instead of Arabic language on an Arabic system.Oct 29 2017, 2:18 PM

Not sure why @alanajjar closed this task as "resolved" when there was no code change that changed something...?

@David: Please see https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T174434#3561974 how to provide sufficient and clear information, to allow developers to investigate.

@debt The translation does not appear in Android

@David: Which browsers and which browser versions did you test on which Android versions? Please see https://mediawiki.org/wiki/How_to_report_a_bug

I was able to produce the arabic version of the page on mobile by going to system settings on Android and changing the language to Arabic.
However, in the process I discovered a rendering bug T179273 :(

Hi @David - please let us know how to reproduce what you're seeing on your android device; screenshots are also nice to have. :)

@Aklapper I believe that this ticket was closed earlier by @alanajjar because there wasn't a bug, as I described in my response: T174434#3567944, I believe that they weren't setting their browser preferred language correctly.

I'll close this out, as it was probably due to user error.