How has search been affected by changes to mobile main page which rolled out March 26 (T190101)?
See T185584 for additional context.
• atgo | |
Mar 30 2018, 11:17 PM |
F16642720: Screen Shot 2018-04-03 at 2.13.47 PM.png | |
May 2 2018, 11:01 PM |
F17605570: Screen Shot 2018-05-02 at 3.56.33 PM.png | |
May 2 2018, 11:01 PM |
F17605560: overall_search.png | |
May 2 2018, 11:01 PM |
How has search been affected by changes to mobile main page which rolled out March 26 (T190101)?
See T185584 for additional context.
Copy from T191354#4176890
We don't see any spike or dip in the total number of search, zero result rate and clickthrough rate, when the Hindi mobile main page change (March 26th), or when the video campaign launch (April 2nd):
In sum, we don't see any impact on search from mobile main page change or video campaign on Hindi Wikipedia.
@atgo Please let me know if you have any question.
Thanks @chelsyx . Apologies for the very slow response time on this, I've been OOO on sabbatical and just back now.
There are a couple of things I'd like to understand more here.
[...]
App searches seem incorrectly high as compared to desktop or mobile web. In your first screenshot, they look like 2-4x more searches from the app, but the web's traffic overall looks like about 100x that of the app, so I'm finding this hard to believe. Can you clarify what's going on here?
Agree that it would be good to know the answer to this question. (Also, are the data source and queries used for this analysis documented somewhere? Does it have to do with the dataset mentioned at https://wikitech.wikimedia.org/wiki/Analytics/Data_Lake/Traffic/Cirrus ?)
Another thing: Since this task was about changes to the mobile web version specifically, it could have been worth separating mobile web and desktop searches in F17605560. Considering the outcome here, it may not yield more insight in this specific case, but it may be worth keeping in mind for T199726: Understand if ru.wikipedia main page changes had impact on mobile users.
@atgo Sorry about the late response to your question:
Given that we're not able to recover the raw data now, the following answers are based on my best guesses:
- There is a steady drop in app searches across this time. What's that all about?
This looks more like a seasonal change to me.
- App searches seem incorrectly high as compared to desktop or mobile web. In your first screenshot, they look like 2-4x more searches from the app, but the web's traffic overall looks like about 100x that of the app, so I'm finding this hard to believe. Can you clarify what's going on here?
This is likely to be the result of different sampling rate on different platform. So the scale of this metric is not providing a lot of useful information (since it is sampled data), but the trend of the metric is.