Page MenuHomePhabricator

Allow to skip the edit summary step when publishing from VisualEditor
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

Writing an edit summary is usually desirable. However, in some cases, it may be more desirable to skip it. Possible scenarios:

  • Wanting to save frequently so as not to lose work on an unstable computer or connection. Auto-save can help with this, but it's not totally stable itself.
  • Making dozens of similar minor "assembly line" edits, for example correcting a common spelling mistake. In this case, some kind of an automated edit summary could perhaps be a good solution instead of press Publish -> paste a repeated summary -> press Publish.

This was raised by an experienced Wikipedian as one of the main reason why he doesn't use VE much, so there is at least some demand for it.

Event Timeline

I think there is a real problem here (basically: "saving is not fast enough"), but I don't think the proposed solution ("skip the save dialog") is a good one.

Wikipedians often feel very strongly about using edit summaries and I worry that a vocal group would be very mad at us if we made it too easy to skip them. (And as a Wikipedian, I would agree with them, except I wouldn't be mad. :) ) Additionally, this would presumably require a preference or something, which has a maintenance burden.

But there may be different ways to make saving faster and more convenient…

One that immediately came to mind is using keyboard shortcuts, which we already support – on desktop, you can press Alt+Shift+S (or Alt+S, depending on the browser) and then Ctrl+Enter to save your edit in about 2 seconds :) (Ctrl+Enter is a generic shortcut that works in all dialogs). But I'll admit that this is a bit of finger gymnastics, and perhaps not exposed/documented well enough.