Page MenuHomePhabricator

[WFD] Support WFD Ecological status
Open, Needs TriagePublic10 Estimated Story Points

Description

Full Wikidata support for Ecological status

Includes:

  • A Property for the overall status
  • Allowed values mapped to wikidata items
  • A Property for the status per Quality element
  • Allowed qe types mapped to wikidata items
  • Rules for qualifiers and other types of mappings.

Event Timeline

Lokal_Profil set the point value for this task to 10.

For the values. Might it be better to have an item for each value (rather than a number)?. Compare with [[ https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P814 | P814 ]].

Is it desirable to have a property for the qeCode. To be added to each of the allowed target values for qeCode? (or should this be solved by having each of them share a P31) (compare with [[ https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q14545628 | Q14545628 ]].

Review discussions for why a separate prpperty for overall status is preferred over having the same as for qeStatus (and distinguishing them by qualifiers).

Suggested names are EU Ecological Status for Water Body and EU Ecological Quality Element Status for Water Body

Motivation for separating the two is that the EU Ecological Status value is an overall value supported by the values of the values for the Quality Elements. This is done in such a way that any failing QE results in a failing status overall. The decision to split the two was taken in the 2016-06-09 meeting.

Note that Ecological status is on the same level as Chemical status (and Morphological status for GWB).

For overall status (swEcologicalStatusOrPotentialValue) a property was created at P4002 and the allowed values may be found in d:User:AndreCostaWMSE-bot/WFD/swEcologicalStatusOrPotentialValue.

swEcologicalAssessmentYear: should be used as a qualifier for the overall status. This might be either a P585, for a single year, or a P580 + P582 pair, for a range of years.

swEcologicalAssessmentYear is the date-range for measurements... BUT the value is the official one for 2016.

Date qualifier discussion can be found on this page

Waiting on the proposed Chemical Status property to be resolved.

See qeStatusOrPotentialValue in the living documentation for questions related to the QE property.

Lokal_Profil renamed this task from Support WFD Ecological status to [WFD] Support WFD Ecological status.Jan 17 2020, 10:58 AM