Page MenuHomePhabricator

Make Meta's global preferences include everything
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

Problem: Many wikis have slightly different configs and therefore slightly different prefs showing. For example, enabling StructuredDiscussions on your user talk page is only an option at a few wikis, and VisualEditor is a Beta Feature for Chinese Wikipedia because of its complex script situation, but not at ~95% of the other Wikipedias.

Actual results: If you want to enable something in GlobalPrefs, you have to know what tab it's in on that wiki, and if what you want to set is not actually available at that wiki (e.g., if you want VisualEditor enabled on all the Wikipedias, regardless of whether it's currently classified as a Beta Feature or normal pref), then you have to switch to another wiki (and another and another) until you find one that has it.

Expectation: There should be at least one place (and if it's only one, then that place should be Meta-wiki) for which it's possible to find and enable/disable all the prefs for all SUL wikis.

See also: T199258: Add a warning message to global preferences page saying that preferences are only for the wiki was scoped down to a request for a MediaWiki message that tells you that to get your account set up properly, you're going to have to visit a bunch of different GlobalPrefs pages on a bunch of different wikis. That's a reasonable interim step, but this is the request to (someday) do the hard work necessary to make it possible to set all your GlobalPrefs without visiting a bunch of different GlobalPrefs pages on a bunch of different wikis.

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added subscribers: Stang, Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript

Just came to report that "global preferences" aren't global, but it seems like it has come up already. Another example: on meta you can make all edits minor by default, but on enwiki you can't. This changes what options are shown in Special:GlobalPreferences. But, can I suggest that, instead of only showing all options on meta, always showing all options, with a disclaimer that they only apply to wikis where the option is valid?