|Resolved||Qgil||T553 Engineering Community team goals for October 2014|
|Resolved||Qgil||T174 Launch Wikimedia Phabricator Day 1|
|Resolved||Qgil||T15 Migrate Bugzilla to Phabricator|
|Resolved||• chasemp||T259 Bugzilla to Maniphest import script (tracking)|
|Declined||• chasemp||T264 Add all people who have voted on a Bugzilla ticket to the Subscribers (CC) list of the corresponding ticket in Maniphest|
- Mentioned In
- T618: Send two email notifications to active Bugzilla users asking them to join Phabricator
T390: Inform users that their Bugzilla tag entries and votes will not be transfered to Phab
T847: Get every previous Bugzilla user with actions have an account, so that actions aren't attributed to bzimport
T259: Bugzilla to Maniphest import script (tracking)
qgil wrote on 2014-07-11 14:03:56 (UTC)
Just checking. In order to CC Bugzilla users to Phabricator tasks, those old users must exist as new users in Phabricator during the migration process. @Rush, does this factor fit in your idea of how Bugzilla users would be created/claimed in Phabricator?
Rush wrote on 2014-07-11 14:07:57 (UTC)
I think yes, but voting in the New Phab World Order we are thinking is more akin to awarding a token (pleased/displeased) while cc'ing comes with notifications and it being in the mix for your dashboards and such. I don't know if we can automate token giving via api, but are we sure vote => cc is what we want?
aklapper wrote on 2014-07-14 11:25:15 (UTC)
are we sure vote => cc is what we want?
We don't have any data which interpretations and motivations for voting on a bug report in Bugzilla are the most common ones (and I am not aware of any literature on this topic either).
Personally I lean towards not automatically turning votes into CC'ing people when migrating from Bugzilla to Phabricator - if people wanted to be CC'ed, they could have CC'ed themselves in addition to voting (and I think if you already managed to cope with Bugzilla's horrible Voting UI then CC'ing yourself should have been a smaller challenge).
qgil wrote on 2014-07-14 12:51:08 (UTC)
I just realized that votng in Bugzilla doesn't add you to the CC list. Therefore I agree, voters in Bugzilla shouldn't be converted to CCed in Phabricator.
aklapper wrote on 2014-07-14 14:03:20 (UTC)
The problem is that https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/userprefs.cgi?tab=email by default has some checkboxes enabled for "When my relationship to this bug is Voter, I want to receive mail when ..."
I wonder if it's worth to run a SQL query to check which settings are common among people.
aklapper wrote on 2014-07-16 20:09:51 (UTC)
Yes (though I'm not sure that "Resolved" is better than "Wontfix").
No matter what, some people will be unhappy. In this case if I can choose between some people slightly interested in a ticket but not CCed on it vs. some people suddenly getting spammed with bugmail, I prefer to not spam.
aklapper wrote on 2014-08-12 17:30:52 (UTC)
And just for the records and to document it: We cannot export votes via Bugzilla's API. http://www.bugzilla.org/docs/4.4/en/html/api/Bugzilla/WebService/Bug.html says "Searching by votes was removed in Bugzilla 4.0.", reference: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=577049