Page MenuHomePhabricator

The new discussion tool should provide guidance to discourage talk forks
Open, Needs TriagePublicFeature

Description

Problem: Newcomers frequently make the mistake of starting the same discussion in multiple places, which goes against w:WP:TALKFORK. This creates a lot of messiness: it uses up editor time because folks type out comments others have already given elsewhere, makes it harder to keep track of things, requires work to reconcile differing outcomes, can be seen as inappropriate canvassing/forum shopping, etc.

Proposed solution: The new discussion tool could help address this issue by identifying possible discussion forks as they happen. The trigger for this would be if a non-extended confirmed editor starts writing a new topic that has the same header as a topic they recently (say, within 31 hours) started at a different page. (A more advanced version could parse the content as well, looking for, say, > 90% similarity.) When that condition is met, it would trigger an editnotice (or an implementation of Edit check) that would say something like "Please do not start the same discussion in multiple places. To draw attention to a centralized discussion, use the Please see template to leave an invitation."

Initial discussion here.